Starring Roll: Justin Warner's Mashed Potato-Peanut Butter Candy

By: Food Network Magazine

Justin Warner doesn't play by the rules. He eats jellyfish on Thanksgiving, serves cold-pizza terrine at his Brooklyn restaurant and writes rap songs about wine. But when Alton Brown, Giada De Laurentiis and Bobby Flay had to choose their teams of aspiring stars for the most recent season of Food Network Star, Justin's unconventional approach caught Alton's eye. Alton picked Justin for his group, and throughout the season Justin was a rebel, presenting wild combos like peanut butter–stuffed dates topped with seaweed. In the end, after 4.5 million viewers voted, Justin emerged as the winner. He says Alton's guidance made all the difference. "It was a true mentorship," Justin says. "Day one, Alton said, 'No apologies.' That's how you win."

Although Justin has been busy planning his new show (coming this fall), we managed to pull him aside for a quick Thanksgiving assignment: Come up with a fun new way to use leftover mashed potatoes. Justin took an old-fashioned candy idea and turned it on its head. Traditional mashed-potato candy is made with peanut butter, but Justin added umeboshi paste (Japanese plum paste) as a twist on peanut butter and jelly. Try the recipe (pictured after the jump).

Photo by: Kang Kim

Kang Kim

Keep Reading

Next Up

A Healthier Spin on Candied Yams

Ever wonder how many calories get racked up at Thanksgiving? Americans consume 4,500 calories on the day of the feast. But a little knowledge is power.

Yeast Rolls: A Homemade Breadbasket Favorite

Food Network's Yeast Rolls are a comforting side dish for your Thanksgiving feast.

Thanksgiving Breadbasket Recipes: Cornbread, Rolls and Biscuits Galore

Bread is best baked fresh. Pass a breadbasket around your Thanksgiving table loaded with fresh-from-the-oven cornbread, biscuits and more.

Spotlight Recipe: Peanut Butter & Chocolate Biscotti

These peanut butter and chocolate biscotti pieces are bit time- and energy-intensive, but at a five-dozen yield, they are certainly worth the effort.

Apple Butter Braised Pork Chops — The Weekender

Looking for a new potluck dish to add to your holiday repertoire? Look no further than Sunny's Apple Butter Braised Pork Chops.

Weekly Bits: Nutty For Peanut Butter

Peanut butter, it seems, is personal. After we tried a few brands in our taste test, we were flooded with suggestions of jars to try. One of our readers even had a great way to use peanut butter in a favorite dip. On the holiday front, if you're still stuck on gifts to get your foodie friend, look no further than this week's list of reader comments.

Have a Question About Making Thanksgiving Dinner? Ask Us

FoodNetwork.com will answer all of your Thanksgiving questions on Saturday, Nov. 22 beginning at noon EST. Find out how to submit a question.

Food Network Apps

In the Kitchen

Get over 70,000 FN recipes on all your mobile devices.

Facebook Messenger

Ask our bot for recipes, meal ideas and daily food trivia.

Amazon Echo

Just say "Alexa, enable Food Network skill" to get started.