Thanksgiving in a Cone? Portland Scoop Shop Reimagines the Feast

Would you try turkey-flavored ice cream? Salted Caramel Thanksgiving Turkey, to be exact – made with turkey-fat caramel and speckled with fried-turkey skin brittle? Bacon has already crossed over into dessert territory, and now at one adventurous ice cream shop, poultry is getting in the game.

This month at Portland’s Salt & Straw, the Thanksgiving feast has been reimagined as a five-course menu of ice cream flavors. Co-owner Tyler Malek and R&D manager Kat Whitehead fine-tuned their seasonal flavors for months, and when FN Dish visited Portland over the summer, they gave us a sneak peek at the process of turning the classic holiday meal into a sweet, creamy flight.

Not surprisingly, channeling Thanksgiving’s piece de resistance – the turkey – proved the biggest challenge for these ice cream artisans. “We’ve been working on that recipe for over two years now!” Malek told us. It took about 20 batches before their final Salted Caramel Thanksgiving Turkey recipe was pronounced ready to scoop. “We were confident this flavor would work,” Malek said. “We tried a couple of different renditions but loved the idea of crispy skin in the form of candied brittle and really pushed the limits on what that could look like in ice cream.”

To round out the Turkey Day ice cream feast, there are flavors inspired by classic sides: Sweet Potato Casserole with Maple Pecans, Hazelnut Rosemary Stuffing and Honey-Bourbon Corn Pudding. “Most of these recipes are actually inspired by my own family recipes,” Malek explained. “I grew up with a family from Montana, so all those casseroles, bread puddings, and ‘salads’ definitely hit home for me. I think the Sweet Potato Casserole is my favorite when it comes to nostalgia.” It wouldn’t be Thanksgiving without pumpkin pie, so Spiced Chevre Pumpkin Pie ice cream marks the official “dessert” of the flight.

If you don’t live near Portland or Los Angeles, where the latest Salt & Straw outpost recently opened, you can still feast on their Thanksgiving ice creams this month. All of the flavors can be ordered on Salt & Straw’s website and shipped anywhere in the United States. The flavors are also available by the scoop, flight or pint at all Salt & Straw scoop shops from Nov. 1 – Nov. 29. For every Thanksgiving pint purchased at a scoop shop, Salt & Straw will donate a pint to the  Oregon Food Bank for their Thanksgiving meals around the state.

Check out these reimagined Thanksgiving desserts from Food Network.

Photos by Leela Cyd Ross and Sara Levine
Keep Reading

Next Up

A 2 a.m. Wake-Up, Dozens of Dinner Guests and a Rescue Ingredient: Thanksgiving According to Bobby Flay

Thanksgiving at Bobby's house starts extra early as he preps for 50 guests and includes two whopping turkeys. Hear from him to learn his tried-and-true Thanksgiving tips.

Worry-Free Wine Presentation at Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving can bring out the worry. Happily, there's one area that doesn't require excessive concern, and that's wine presentation. Here are my stress-relieving tips:

Turkey Taboos: What NOT to Do This Thanksgiving

With these words of wisdom in your back pocket, your beloved bird will taste better than ever this Thanksgiving.

How to Get Crispy Skin — Thanksgiving Tip of the Day

For crisper skin, unwrap the turkey the day before roasting and leave it uncovered in the refrigerator overnight.

Spatchcocking: Tyler Florence's Revolutionary Technique for Cooking Your Thanksgiving Turkey in 90 Minutes

Cook your Thanksgiving turkey in 90 minutes this year with Tyler Florence’s spatchcocking technique.

Best 5 Ways to Dress Up Your Thanksgiving Turkey

Stick to Food Network's best-ever turkey recipes to put an impressive spin on your holiday bird.

Beyond the Turkey: All About Wine on Thanksgiving, According to Alex Guarnaschelli

Hear from Alex Guarnaschelli about how to utilize wine during and after your Thanksgiving feast.

Wine Will Keep Well; Buy It Early — Thanksgiving Tip of the Day

Should you drink red or white with turkey? Don't fret if you're new to wine, there's no wrong answer, but we've got some picks to get you started.

Thanksgiving Wines Paired With Your Menu Style

Every year, we get questions on how to pair wine with Thanksgiving dinner; it’s a nice dinner you’ve gone to great lengths to prepare, and you want to drink something nice with it. This is both a hard question to answer and an easy one, because turkey itself is a blank canvas — you can pair it with pretty much every wine in the world and it’ll work pretty well — so it’s never so much about the turkey as it is about the seasonings and sides. The problem here is actually that there’s too much choice.