Why Wacky Ice Cream Flavors (Chorizo? Poutine?) Are the New Normal

Why do we seek out oddities, when the flavors we already have — including chocolate chip and mint chip, cookies 'n' cream, and fudge ripple — are so delicious? Here’s the scoop.
Assorted ice cream

Assorted ice cream

Remember when ice cream came in basically three flavors: chocolate, vanilla and strawberry? At a certain point, the options grew to include at least 31. But even those of us who favor flavors like rocky road, pralines and cream, and Jamoca Almond Fudge probably never imagined a world in which foie gras, bacon, chorizo, salt and pepper, and durian-banana ice creams were a thing.

Yet here we are in a world of ice cream flavors that are — shall we say? — unusual. Why do we seek out such oddities, when the flavors we already have — including chocolate chip and mint chip, cookies 'n' cream, and fudge ripple — are so delicious?

Eater has taken a look at the wacky-ice-cream-flavor trend. Here are a few takeaways:

1.  Weird flavors are actually not such a new thing. Historians have found 18th century ice cream recipes for flavors including raspberry and apricot as well as coffee, tea, pistachio, Parmesan and chocolate, which, unlike the chocolate we eat today, may have been “cayenne spicy.” There’s even documentation from Colonial times for an oyster ice cream. “Essentially it was frozen oyster chowder,” Robert Brantley, a journeyman at Colonial Williamsburg’s Historic Foodways, said. “They served it unsweetened, with the oysters strained out.” And you thought that scoop of caramel balsamic swirl you ate last night was pushing it.

2.  There’s a psychological explanation. People are primed to seek out new and different flavors because it’s a safe risk. “Psychologists call this phenomenon ‘brief sensation seeking,’ and while it's most often applied to the pleasure gained from eating spicy foods, it can also be used to explain why customers keep coming back to creameries,” Eater Detroit editor Brenna Houck wrote. Plus, ice cream parlors traditionally let you sample a flavor before committing to a whole scoop, which makes trying an unusual flavor even less risky — and potentially more rewarding.

3.  It’s a good way to stand out from the crowd. Having an unusual flavor helps an ice cream parlor capture attention — from the press and customers alike. "We've never spent a dime on marketing," Jake Godsby, co-owner of creative San Francisco ice creamery Humphry Slocombe, told Eater. "It helps us get noticed for sure."

In the mood to make your own nontraditional ice cream at home? Here are a few unusual — and unusually addictive — recipes to try.

Photo courtesy of iStock
Keep Reading

Next Up

Ice Cream Politics: Party Flavors

Red states and blue states don't just disagree about politics—they take sides on ice cream flavors, too. Find out what Food Network Magazine uncovered.

Ice Cream Flavor Bombs from The Kitchen

These three knock-out sundaes from your favorite hosts hit all the right notes — salty, sweet, crunchy, smooth. Plus, there's plenty of whipped cream — always a good thing.

3 Ways to Flavor-Bomb Your Ice Cream

Find out how the co-hosts of The Kitchen dress up everyday ice cream flavors to create over-the-top sundaes.

Dominique Ansel's New Innovation: Burrata Ice Cream

Burrata Ice Cream is one of two innovative soft-serve flavors now on offer at the walk-up ice cream window of Dominique Ansel Kitchen.

Morimoto Philadelphia Launches New Take-Home Ice Creams and Sorbets

Iron Chef Masaharu Morimoto’s flagship restaurant, Morimoto Philadelphia, will sell new house-made ice creams and sorbets over the summer.

12 New Pumpkin-Flavored Foods You Gotta Try

Pumpkin products are plentiful this fall. Check out these 12 healthy(ish) pumpkin-flavored foods that take pumpkin beyond lattes and pie.

Summer Fest: Marrying the Apple With New Flavors

Go beyond peanut butter and cinnamon and try marrying your apples with new ingredients in these unexpected and flavorful dishes.

Why We Love Ice Cream

Happy National Ice Cream Day! You can and should indulge in this creamy treat; watch your portions and toppings and the occasional cone is a perfectly reasonable dessert.

Healthy Swaps: Ice Cream Toppings

Ice cream lovers tend to forget that toppings can pile up the calorie and fat. Consider our tips before making your next sundae.