Restaurant Revisited: Caseyville Cafe

Related To:

Although mother-daughter duo Diane Emery and Robin Gordon had no previous experience in the restaurant industry, together they purchased Caseyville Cafe in Caseyville, Ill., more than three years ago. At one point their eatery was making enough money to simply break even with its costs, but it soon turned into a failing venture, with more than $6,000 being lost every month. Just months away from shutting down their business entirely, the ladies looked to Robert Irvine for a complete Restaurant: Impossible overhaul. It soon became clear to Robert that this "dirty, dysfunctional" space was in need of not simply an aesthetic transformation, but also vast changes to its menu and management. In two days and with only $10,000, he worked with Diane and Robin to revamp all aspects of Caseyville Cafe, which ultimately reopened with crowd-pleasing food and a roomful of satisfied customers. We checked in with Robin a few months after Robert left to find out how her business is doing today.

Since its Restaurant: Impossible debut, Caseyville Cafe has had an increase in business. Although they're still working to manage supply costs, Robin and Diane are slowly minimizing their debt.

Much of the front-of-house staff remains at the restaurant, and the servers are now taking better care of their customers. Diane and Robin still struggle with gossip among the servers, but Robin notes that her mother "has been trying to improve" in her communications with the staff. "My mother has been spending more time at the cafe. She has been doing the majority of the management," she tells us.

Robin adds that "the food has improved and is consistent" at Caseyville. The restaurant is now featuring both its original menu and Robert's new offerings, but Robin says that "the ribeye and asparagus have been a success."

Looking back on her Restaurant: Impossible experience, Robin believes its most-valuable result to be the effect it has had on Diane. "I think Robert has finally made my mother realize that she needs to take the cafe more seriously or else it will close," she explains.

More From Restaurant Revisited:

Dinner Bell Restaurant (February 27)
Sapori D'Italia (January 23)
Windseeker Restaurant (January 16)
Rising Sun Bistro (December 19)
Bronk's Bar and Grill (December 5)
Rohrer's Tavern (November 28)
Poco's on the Boulevard (November 21)
Oleander Bar and Grill (October 17)
Valley Inn (October 10)
Whistle Stop (October 3)
The Maple Tree Cafe (September 26)
Michele's (September 19)
Paliani's Restaurant (September 12)
Frankie's (September 5)
Gusanoz (August 29)
Keep Reading

Next Up

Restaurant Revisited: The Maple Tree Cafe

We talked to the owner of The Maple Tree Cafe to see how the restaurant is doing after their Restaurant Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Recipe for Disaster at Papa C's Eastside Cafe

Find out how Papa C's Eastside Cafe is doing after its transformation on Food Network's Restaurant: Impossible.

Restaurant Revisited: Soul Searching at Georgia Boy Cafe

Find out how Georgia Boy Cafe is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Revved Up at Shade Tree Customs and Cafe

Find out how Shade Tree Customs and Cafe is doing after its transformation on Restaurant: Impossible.

Restaurant Revisited: Culture Clash at Marie's at Ummat Cafe

Find out how Marie's at Ummat Cafe is doing after its transformation on Food Network's Restaurant: Impossible.

Restaurant Revisited: Nanny Goat's Cafe & Feed Bin

Find out how Nanny Goat's Cafe & Feed Bin is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Windseeker Restaurant

Find out how Windseeker Restaurant is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Paliani’s Restaurant

We checked in with the owner of Paliani's to see how the restaurant is doing after their Restaurant Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: No Day at the Beach at Portu-Greek Cafe

Find out how Portu-Greek Cafe is doing after its transformation on Food Network's Restaurant: Impossible.

Restaurant Revisited: Going Down with the Ship at Gigi's Music Cafe

Find out how Gigi's Music Cafe has been doing since Robert relaunched the business.