Diner vs. BBQ: Which Restaurant Divided Concept Did You Like Better?

"Anytime you mix friendship with business, there's always inherent conflict, and you can see it's sort of coming to the surface," Restaurant Divided's Rocco DiSpirito said not long after arriving at Against Da Grill, a Staten Island, N.Y., eatery specializing in diner-style classics. Co-owners Kurron Mangin and Vinny Lima — the chef and the business manager at Against Da Grill, respectively — are longtime best friends facing imminent closure of their restaurant if they can't turn around the business. While Kurron is committed to maintaining the original diner concept at Against Da Grill, Vinny believes a change is in order and proposed they begin serving traditional barbecue instead. "I feel that the Island is missing that," Vinny explained. "If we could bring something that no one else is doing, we have a better chance at success."

The team at Against Da Grill is a tightknit one: The staff is like family, and the restaurant is well-ingrained in the community. So for Rocco to decide what the best next step should be for Against Da Grill, he ultimately divided it. After a complete interior overhaul and menu redesign, Kurron served customers at the new Against Da Grill while Vinny ran S.I.Q. on the other side of the restaurant. Rocco listened to customer and critic feedback, tasted dishes from both eateries and reviewed both restaurants' chances for lasting success before deciding that S.I.Q. offered the most opportunity for viability.

Do you think Rocco made the correct decision in choosing to open S.I.Q., or would you have rather seen Against Da Grill be given a second chance? Tell FN Dish in the poll below: Which Restaurant Divided concept did you like better?

Tune in to Restaurant Divided on Thursdays at 10pm/9c.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Steaks vs. Sports: Which Restaurant Divided Concept Did You Like Better?

Cast your vote to tell FN Dish which concept featured on Food Network's Restaurant Divided you liked better.

Gyros vs. Tacos: Which Restaurant Divided Concept Did You Like Better?

Cast your vote to tell FN Dish which concept featured on Food Network's Restaurant Divided you liked better.

Quiz: Which Food Truck Concept Are You?

Do you dream of putting your cooking chops and navigation skills to the test on The Great Food Truck Race? Take the quiz to find out which food truck concept you'd do best at.

Burgers vs. Ribs: Which Gets Your Vote (and Bite) at the Barbecue?

Cast your vote to tell FN Dish which of these meaty bites is your ultimate cookbook favorite.

Restaurant Revisited: Soup to Nuts Diner

Find out how Soup to Nuts Diner is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Which is Healthier: Fruit Cobbler vs. Fruit Pie

Summer is all about fruit-filled desserts. When faced with the choice of cobbler or pie, which would you choose? Read the pros and cons of each and YOU vote for the healthier winner!

Hash Browns vs. Home Fries: Which Is Better?

Which is better: hash browns or home fries? Vote now.