Restaurant Revisited: NY State of Mind at Mama Della's N.Y. City Pizzeria

Related To:

Change — or a lack thereof — was at the foundation of Robert Irvine's mission at Mama Della's N.Y. City Pizzeria in Baton Rouge, La., a Big Apple-style parlor specializing in family recipes. While Robert indeed identified several issues with the menu at Mama Della's and noted that its interior decor was "very nondescript," perhaps the most-critical problem plaguing the business was owner Barry Kalt, who Robert deemed "one of the most-cantankerous owners I have ever come across." Given his long-standing beliefs in how true dishes and ingredients should be prepared and served, Barry was hesitant to make any meaningful updates to his business practices, which ultimately resulted in his son Andrew, a former cook at Mama Della's, leaving the restaurant. It took a serious lesson from Robert for Barry to fully realize the error of his ways, and he soon committed to improvements in the future. After two days of renovations on a $10,000 budget, the Restaurant: Impossible team reopened Mama Della's, and FN Dish has the exclusive update from Barry on how his business is faring today.

"Mama Della's saw a significant increase in customer traffic for the one-month period after the shoot," Barry said. "Sales have increased by 30 percent over the same period in 2013."

The menu at Mama Della's is a mix of the restaurant's original offerings, plus those that Robert instituted, according to Barry. "The menu changes set in place by Chef Irvine remain exactly as they were when he was in the restaurant," he explained. "Nothing new has actually been added to the menu. We have been preparing certain specialty pizzas and sandwiches that were on the previous menu. These are being requested by customers who have been with us for a long time." Barry noted that since the transformation, "certain menu items are reaching the guests in a more punctilious manner than was the case previously."

Barry said that the new interior "is spectacular," although he admitted, "[It] does not represent the look of a New York City pizzeria. My decor did represent it very well." He added that diners have been pleased with the design updates and that "the decor has almost eliminated comments about price points that are too high."

As for Andrew, he is not working at Mama Della's today.

More from Restaurant Revisited:

Tootie's Texas BBQ (March 12)
Estrada's Restaurant (February 5)
Hillbillies Restaurant (January 29)
Goombazz Big City Eatzz (December 18)
LBI Pancake House (December 8)
Seven (November 27)
Georgia Boy Cafe (November 20)
The Windsor 75 (November 6)
Aponte's Pizzeria (August 25)
Benner Street (July 28)
Kalico Kitchen (July 14)
Angelo's (June 23)
Bryan's Smokehouse (May 26)
Smitty's Restaurant (April 28)
Keep Reading

Next Up

Restaurant Revisited: Mama Lee's

When Robert Irvine and his Restaurant: Impossible team visited Mama Lee’s soul food restaurant in San Antonio, it had never turned a profit and was just weeks away from closing down.

Restaurant Revisited: The Ambush at Tornatore's Pizzeria

Find out how Tornatore's Pizzeria has been doing since Robert relaunched the business.

Restaurant Revisited: Bring Mama Back at Mama Campisi's Restaurant

Find out how Mama Campici's is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: A Pie in the Sky at Aponte's Pizzeria

Find out how Aponte's Pizzeria is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Goombazz Gone Wild at Goombazz Big City Eatzz

Find out how Goombazz Big City Eatzz is doing after its transformation on Food Network's Restaurant: Impossible.

Restaurant Revisited: Paliani’s Restaurant

We checked in with the owner of Paliani's to see how the restaurant is doing after their Restaurant Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Windseeker Restaurant

Find out how Windseeker Restaurant is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Dinner Bell Restaurant

Find out how Dinner Bell Restaurant is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Stella's

We checked in with the Savoies a few months later to see how business is going.

Restaurants Revisited: Top Turnarounds

Find out how some of the restaurants featured on Restaurant: Impossible's top-turnarounds special are doing today.