Restaurant Revisited: Mystic Mystery at Mystic Treats

Find out how Mystic Treats is doing since undergoing a Restaurant: Impossible transformation.
Related To:

Photo by: COYNE

COYNE

"I have no idea what 'Mystic Treats' means," Robert Irvine told husband-and-wife owners Michael and Erika Lowe of the name of their Ashland, Ore., eatery. Though the couple has a shared background in the IT field, the two opened Mystic Treats three years ago and recently relocated it to a space with history as both Mexican and Korean eateries, which only furthered Mystic Treats' oddball identity. After hearing feedback from the community, Robert managed to find his vision for the updated interior, and he tasked his Restaurant: Impossible design and construction teams to bring several themes to life, including "earthy," "vibrant," "quirky — a little bit" and "homey."

When it comes to the food at Mystic Treats, the menu was seemingly as confused as the decor: It offered pizza mash-ups inspired by hot dogs, pasta, and macaroni and cheese, among others. Michael and Erika had been committed to creating every element of their menu from scratch in the restaurant, and while Robert is usually quick to praise such dedication, the finished products coming out of the kitchen didn't shine. "Some of the ideas are good, but the execution of it is not good," Robert told Erika after she saw the reality of her offerings. With some help and inspiration from Robert, however, the couple learned how careful spending on store-bought items and forgoing several homemade products may in turn save them money.

After two days of reinvigorating Erika and Michael, Robert was confident that the two had the tools they needed to give Mystic Treats a second chance at success. But despite Robert's and his team's best efforts, ultimately Mystic Treats closed its doors recently and is no longer open for business.

More from Restaurant Revisited:

Knife and Fork Gastropub (December 15)
Double H Ranch (December 8)
Mama E's Wings & Waffles (November 24)
Papa C's Eastside Cafe (November 3)
Mama Lucrezia's (September 24)
Green Beret Club (September 17)
Spicy Bar and Grill (September 10)
El Bistro (September 3)
Uncle Andy's Diner (August 27)
Paul's Bar & Bowling (August 6)
The Fork Diner (July 23)
Portu-Greek Cafe (June 11)
Bama Q (May 28)
Cave Inn BBQ (May 21)
Urban Roots (April 9)
Pasión Latin Fusion (March 19)
Tootie's Texas BBQ (March 12)
Estrada's Restaurant (February 5)
Keep Reading

Next Up

Restaurant Revisited: Windseeker Restaurant

Find out how Windseeker Restaurant is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Paliani’s Restaurant

We checked in with the owner of Paliani's to see how the restaurant is doing after their Restaurant Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Dinner Bell Restaurant

Find out how Dinner Bell Restaurant is doing after their Restaurant: Impossible renovation with Food Network's Robert Irvine.

Restaurant Revisited: Barolo

In Aptos, Calif., Robert and the Restaurant: Impossible team faced the daunting task of turning things around at Ristorante Barolo.

Restaurant Revisited: Cocoamoda

Find out how Cocoamoda is doing after its transformation on Restaurant: Impossible.

Restaurant Revisited: Pollard's

We checked in with owners Tarrance and Torria Pollard to see how business is going after their Restaurant: Impossible intervention.

Restaurant Revisited: Stella's

We checked in with the Savoies a few months later to see how business is going.

Restaurants Revisited: Top Turnarounds

Find out how some of the restaurants featured on Restaurant: Impossible's top-turnarounds special are doing today.