Food Network

Sponsor Recommendations

Recipe Reviews

Here’s how the rating system works:


Caramel Apple Cheesecake
Recipe courtesy Bobby Flay, 2007
Show:  Throwdown with Bobby Flay   
Episode:  Cheesecake
Overall User Rating: Overall User Rating


Please read the reviews before you make this
07/07/2008 at 08:06pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
Thank goodness for everyone's comments. I didn't use the orange zest, the muscovado sugar, or the vanilla beans. I read the comments listed and listen to the advice and my cheescake came out perfect! It was so good I couldn't even imagine it being as good as it was. It does take some time to complete, but the presentation is flawless and the taste is fantastic.




Love it!!! Love it!!!!
06/29/2008 at 10:33pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
I actually didn't have the vanilla beans, they were way too expensive so I just used a little more vanilla extract. I also didn't make this with the caramel/apple sauce.....it was still to die for. I made this for myself on my birthday last year and everyone loved it just as much as I did!




Wow!
06/29/2008 at 07:57pm
User: Kiley from Omaha, NE    User Rating:
This cheesecake is so creamy and flavorful. I've made many cheesecakes and this one will be added to my favorites! One piece of advice: Skip the caramel recipe and buy caramel sundae topping and drizzle over apples, saves time and the hassle.




Excelent!
04/17/2008 at 04:41pm
User: Wesley from Minden , NV    User Rating:
This dish has a very good balance of flavors! It is a breath of fresh air compared to old style cheesecakes.




loved it
03/25/2008 at 09:40pm
User: terri from alviso, CA    User Rating:
I altered it a touch. took out the walnuts from the crust ( I'm allergic ) and put in cinnamon. and used gran marnier instead of apple brandy, in the caramel sauce. It was a big hit with my friends.




too much juice
01/28/2008 at 01:30pm
User: Jackie from Seattle, WA    User Rating:
I made this cheesecake for a party this weekend following the recipe very carefully. I am an experienced cook and always follow first-time recipes with care. I found that when I added the 6 peeled and sliced apples to the carmelized sugar that had reduced to 1/2 cup, that the juice from the apples as they cooked caused the carmelization to be weakened and there was far too much juice at the end of cooking to put onto the cheescake. I had to strain the apples before doing this, reduce down the liquid to the desired amount and they were not really carmelized enough in my opinion. The caramel sauce I found very weak in quality. The cheesecake itself was good but the topping left something to be desired.




Christmas Eve fabulosity
12/27/2007 at 03:16pm
User: Laura from Sun Prairie, WI    User Rating:
After seeing this episode, I decided I HAD to make this cheesecake for Christmas Eve dessert. I read the reviews and was nervous, but the cheesecake turned out perfect. It is moist and smooth, no cracks (which I have had issues with in the past), and the taste is scrumptious. I should note that I didn't use the brandy as I had some non-drinkers at my table. So, I can't speak to that, but as for rest, YUMMY. My husband tested the apples before I put them on and decided that part alone was wonderful and could even make a slice of Wonder Bread taste good. He was thrilled at the whole package.




GREEEAAT!!
12/07/2007 at 09:00am
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
I loved this recipe and so did my grandchildren it may take time but it was sure worth it in the end




Cheesecake
11/29/2007 at 04:30pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
I thought there were few things wrong with this recipe which I made for family Thanksgiving. The brandy was too strong and also there was to much orange flavor in the crust. Other than that I thought it was great!




Love This Cheesecake
11/27/2007 at 10:41am
User: Amanda from Lansing, MI    User Rating:
I have made this cheesecake three times now and everyone asks me for the receipe. I love the taste and texture. I have never found the muscovado sugar but use light brown sugar instead which seems to work well. I also prefer the carmel without the apple brandy but do like it in the apples. This is a great receipe, especially when you make small changes to make it meet your tastes!!




what's up with the texture?
11/24/2007 at 02:04pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
Hmmm....I wasn't as impressed with this recipe as I was hoping. Cheesecakes are one of my favorite things to bake, so I was tempted to tweak it myself, but I didn't, I followed the recipe exactly. Except the apple brandy was the only thing that I was unable to find. The texture didn't turn out like a true rich cheesecake, it was like a firm baked custurd and the orange flavor was too strong against the apples. I loved the crust and the topping and would definatly do those again....on my own cheesecake recipe. The best things that I took away from this recipe: finding a delicious new sugar, great new crust and loved the brandy caramel!!




yum-mo!~
11/19/2007 at 06:22pm
User: Dawn from vail, AZ    User Rating:
best darn cheesecake I ever had.




Not bad, not great
11/09/2007 at 10:39pm
User: Cait from Portsmouth, VA    User Rating:
I thought the brandy was a little too strong in all of it.




Not so good - dry and blah!
10/08/2007 at 09:50am
User: carey from charlotte, NC    User Rating:
I followed the recipe EXACTLY - NO CHANGES. Unfortunately the curst tasted bitter and cheesecake itself seemed dry and not at all the rich cheesecake I was hoping for. My oven temp is fine (I tested it) - cheesecakes should be cooked at a lower temp. My gut told me this was way too high, but I followed the recipe anyway. I shouldn't have. The apples and carmel turned out well (thank goodness) because without it, the desert would have been unedible. Sorry Bobby - stick to the grill!




Muscovado Sugar
10/03/2007 at 05:58am
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
Muscovado Muscovado is a type of unrefined sugar with a strong molasses flavour. It is also known as Barbados or moist sugar. It is very dark brown in color, and slightly coarser and stickier than most brown sugars. Unlike most brown sugars, which are composed of refined white sugar ... Muscovado Muscovado is a type of unrefined sugar with a strong molasses flavour. It is also known as Barbados or moist sugar. It is very dark brown in color, and slightly coarser and stickier than most brown sugars. Unlike most brown sugars, which are composed of refined white sugar ...




What is it?
10/02/2007 at 08:31pm
User: Mary from Upland, CA    User Rating:
I would Love to make this because it sounds great but WHAT THE HECK IS MUSCOVADO SUGAR????




Lay Person
10/02/2007 at 01:27am
User: Randy from Rogers, TX    User Rating:
I have been cooking for 30 plus years and in all those years I have never heard of muscovado sugar. I think sometimes your chef's forget that most of the people trying out their recipes are every day house wifes as well as men to doing the cooking. People who are un famillar with these products and have no way of knowing what to use in stead... Just dumb here in TX




YUM!
09/30/2007 at 08:51pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
This was fantastic. I didn't use Apple Brandy since it was so expensive. I just added some apple juice to the caramel. Rave reviews!




So delicious!
08/29/2007 at 11:58am
User: sheri from aberdeen, SD    User Rating:
I used less sugar, but this was a really delicious cheesecake in combination with the caramel and apples.




Genius
06/30/2007 at 05:28pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
this is one of the best cheesecakes i've ever tasted. It was also the very first cheesecake i've ever baked and it was simple!! It really made me look like a pro!




WOW
05/14/2007 at 03:15pm
User: Anonymous    User Rating:
The best cheesecake period.




Outstanding Must Try!
05/12/2007 at 11:01am
User: Suzie from Fairfield, CT    User Rating:
I thought this cheesecake recipe was awesome. Not only was it easy to follow but everyone is still talking about it. A true keeper. The only thing I altered was the apple brandy. I thought it was very strong so I opted to use less. I also served it with the apples and carmel on the side so people could apply their own toppings. It was a big hit!




awesom
04/18/2007 at 10:31pm
User: debbie from indianapolis, IN    User Rating:
this is a great dessert try it a tremendously great cheesecake




'wow' em recipe!
04/12/2007 at 05:16pm
User: jodi from Bryan, OH    User Rating:
I've never made cheesecake before and decided to try this one for my first attempt. It turned out fantastic! We had it for Easter dinner and my family raved about it. I didn't have what was needed to make the carmal apple topping so I just made a fresh fruit and glaze instead. My sister-in-law works in the kitchen of a fancy resturant and she said it was the best she'd ever had!




awesome cheesecake
04/07/2007 at 12:16pm
User: mike from loxley, AL    User Rating:
i seen this recipe on throwdown/bobbyflay so i made it and it was great maybe not as good as bobby's but good.delicious




GR8
04/06/2007 at 01:40pm
User: lubna from milwaukee, WI    User Rating:
ITS GREAT !!! I HAVE TRIED THIS