Cutthroat Patio: What to Do When Your Grill Sabotages You


As shocking as it might be to believe, sometimes it’s not a scheming rival chef who’s throwing a wrench into your carefully planned meal. Sometimes the metaphorical call is coming from inside the house – or outside on the patio, as the case may be. Here’s a quick rundown of our top 5 grilling mishaps, and how to avoid them.

1) Getting lit: In an ideal world, you'd have a chimney starter (our go-to way of getting coals lit when we’re grilling) — but if you don't, arrange the coals in a pyramid around a few crumpled sheets of newspaper, use a long match to light the newspaper, and then wait for the coals to turn white. Lighter fluid (and match-light charcoal, which is charcoal that has lighter fluid added) tends to add a harsh chemical taste to the food you’re grilling, and it's not our favorite.

2) Stuck food: Once your grill's hot, lightly saturate a paper towel with oil and, using tongs, swipe it gently over the surface of the grates. Also, food will stick less to a clean grill, and grills are easiest to clean when they're hot, so brush your grill down well once you're done cooking. 

3) Uneven cooking: Are you ending up with meat that's scorched through on the outside and raw on the inside? Build yourself a two-zone fire, either by banking charcoal more on one side than the other or by turning one side's burners on and the other's off — now you've got somewhere to sear and somewhere to roast, so everything ends up perfect.

4) Flaring up: Flare-ups are a pretty common side effect of cooking anything juicy. If the food is small and not touching the meat, just keep an eye on it, and know your cook time may be a little shorter than anticipated; if it's big, either move the food to the cooler zone of your grill (if you have one) or remove the food and cover the grill with its lid until the flare-up dies down. Some cooks like water spray bottles to tame flare-ups, but we've found that depriving flames of oxygen is generally a more-reliable and less-splattery way to go.

5) Overcooking: Just as with any other cooking method, remember that food will need to rest after it comes off the heat, and that its internal temperature will rise while that happens. Pull meats off the grill about 5 degrees below (or a few minutes before) where you'd like them to end up, and they'll do the rest on their own.

Next Up

How to Grill Salmon

Everything you need to know, including how long to grill salmon.

How to Grill Chicken

Our grilling tips yield juicy, perfectly cooked chicken breast every time.

Pellet Grills 101: Your Guide to Cooking on a Smoker

Pellet grills can do the work of a smoker, grill and oven — all in your backyard. Here's why you need one, pronto.

5 Best Gas Grills of 2024, According to Experts

When warm weather comes, we’re cooking outdoors as much as we can. That’s why we know which gas grills are best for everything from burgers to veggies.

5 Best Charcoal Grills of 2024, According to Experts

Love smoky flavor? Like to spend time cooking outdoors? A charcoal grill is for you!

6 Best Portable Grills of 2024, According to Experts

Make sure you're ready to cook wherever you go!

How to Grill Corn on the Cob With and Without Husks

Say bye-bye to burnt kernels and dried-out cobs — follow these tips for perfect grilled corn.

How to Smoke a Brisket

Making a whole brisket is a labor of love. Here’s what to know about buying, butchering and smoking it to perfection.

How to Plant and Grow Ginger

You can even plant the knob you bought at the supermarket and enjoy home-grown ginger all year long.

The Ultimate Packable Picnic

Practically any food eaten outdoors in the company of another could qualify as a picnic — "A jug of wine, a loaf of bread and Thou" being among the simplest and best menus still in use more than a thousand years after a poet first suggested it. But once the guest list numbers above three, a few more dishes are in order and a little strategizing pays off. To help plan your next outing, we've assembled a list of totable foods that are easy to eat sprawled out in the sun, plus some handy gear for serving it.