Taste Test: Hot Chocolate

With snow piling up throughout most of the country, a steaming cup of cocoa is a perfect way to warm up. Worried about all the added sugar? We tasted popular brands and will tell you how they measured up.
Related To:
137451683

137451683

Hot chocolate in a cup isolated on white

Photo by: janeff

janeff

Spring may be officially here, but cooler temperatures keep coming back for more. Get through what's hopefully the last cold snap of the season with a steaming cup of hot cocoa. We rated 5 popular brands, looking at taste and the amount of added sugar -- find out our top picks.

The Criteria

We looked at 5 popular brands of powdered cocoa mix — some made with milk chocolate and some made from dark chocolate. We rated each on a 5-point scale (5 being highest) based on flavor, texture and nutritional content. Each hot chocolate was made according to the package directions, which usually was to mix with 6 or 8 fluid ounces of milk (skim milk for our taste test.)  Nutrition information is given for the chocolate powder without the addition of milk.

Rating: 3.5
Cost: $3.99/10.9 ounce container

Nutrition Info Per 2 Tablespoons: 60 calories; 0.5 grams fat; 13 grams sugar

Our Take: The label touts that it contains 25-percent less sugar than other leading syrup brands, but it still was overwhelmingly sugary with a not-so-chocolatey flavor. The first ingredient listed was sugar which is not surprising based on how it tasted. It also was the only brand that fortified its product with several vitamins and minerals like vitamin C, calcium, vitamin B6 and biotin — something not really necessary for a hot chocolate mix.

Rating: 4.0
Cost: $6.29/16-ounce canister

Nutrition Info Per 4 Tablespoons: 140 calories; 1.5 grams fat; 31 grams sugar

Our Take: One of the more expensive of the bunch, our 5-year old kid taster claimed this hot chocolate “tastes like a brownie!” Sweet ground chocolate and processed cocoa are the first 2 ingredients, but it does have a much richer chocolate flavor than many of the other brands. The 4 tablespoon suggested serving size could be cut down to 2, which would maintain that delicious flavor while cutting the calories and sugar in half.

Rating: 4.0
Cost: $9.95/8-ounce canister

Nutrition Info Per 3 Tablespoons: 95 calories; 3 grams fat; 10 grams sugar;

Our Take: There are two ingredients in this powder: cocoa and sugar. If you’re looking for a true bittersweet chocolate flavor, then this is for you. Using skim or low fat milk as opposed to hot water will help increase the sweetness and cut the bitterness. To make it worth the money, halve the suggested portion.

Rating: 3.0
Cost: $2.79/8 (1.25 ounce) envelopes

Nutrition Info Per Envelope: 150 calories; 3.5 grams fat; 18 grams sugar

Our Take: Within the first 4 ingredients, you’ll find sugar, corn syrup and hydrogenated coconut oil (a.k.a. trans fat.) Even though this claims to be dark chocolate, don’t fall for the marketing claim. The benefits of the dark chocolate won’t be found in this hot cocoa mix. Though the  flavor wasn’t among the favorites, it did have a darker chocolate flavor, it was still very, very sweet.

Rating: 3.5
Cost: $1.50/8 (1.25 ounce) envelopes

Nutrition Info Per Envelope: 80 calories; 3 grams fat; 12 grams sugar;

Our Take: Once again sugar, corn syrup and partially hydrogenated vegetable oil (a.k.a. trans fat) appear on the label, but this time as the first 3 ingredients. The flavor tastes likes your average overly-sweetened ski lodge hot chocolate. Save your money and use half an envelope per portion, which will also save you calories and sugar.

TELL US: What’s your favorite hot chocolate brand?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

Check Out Our Other Taste Tests:

Keep Reading

Next Up

Spooky Taste Test: Dark Chocolate

In the spirit of Halloween, we polled our Facebook fans and taste tested your favorite brands of dark chocolate. Read up on the spooky nutrition facts and learn if your favorite dark chocolate is really a treat or just tricky marketing.

Chocolate Tasting Guide

Learn how to taste and select chocolate like a pro.

6 Ways to Warm Up with Flavored Hot Chocolate

If the season's chill has you cozying up under a blanket, try one of these comforting cocoas to warm up from the inside out.

Chocolate Guide

Buy, use and store the best chocolate for your baking needs.

Inside Scoop: Hot New Foods

Is your head swirling with all the newest “healthy” products you see on market shelves? I just attended the annual Food & Nutrition Conference and Expo in San Diego, California where I was able to check out several hot new items. Here are my top 7 favorite finds.

Chocolate Raspberry Trifle

A trifle is a great make-and-take picnic dessert; bring this chocolate and raspberry layered treat to your next picnic.

Chocolate 5 Ways

Just a touch of chocolate is all you need to remind that special someone how you feel. This Valentine’s Day,scrumptious chocolate recipes morning, noon or night.

War of the Chocolates

Chocolate is the aphrodisiac of choice on Valentine’s Day. But not all varieties of this confection are created equal. Here’s a rundown of the most-lovable options for you and your waistline.