Which is Healthier, Lasagna or Mac & Cheese?

Our next head-to-head battle is between two popular pasta entrées. Who’ll win this (comfort) food fight, lasagna or macaroni and cheese?
Related To:

Photo by: Tara Donne ©Tara Donne

Tara Donne, Tara Donne

Our next head-to-head battle is between two popular pasta entrées. We’re pitting cheesy layers of lasagna against gooey mac & cheese. Who’ll win this food fight?

Lasagna

Pros:

If your lasagna includes pasta, veggies, cheese and meat, you’ve got yourself a pretty balanced meal. Plus the tomato sauce is a great way to get in the antioxidant lycopene.

This dish is also easy to modify— pile on more veggies or eliminate the cheese to accomodate a dairy allergy. It’s also a very easy dish to cook and freeze in individual portions—a plus for those busy weeknights.

Cons:

The portions of higher fat ingredients can get out of control, making even a moderate-sized portion a recipe for disaster. Although ground chuck is cheapest, it’s also the highest in fat with over 300 calories and 20 grams of fat per 4 ounces (that’s without any cheese, noodles or other goodies).

The cheese can also get out of control. One cup of whole milk ricotta cheese has 428 calories, 32 grams of fat (20 of which are saturated). Add that to a cup of whole milk shredded mozzarella with 336 calories, 25 grams fat and 15 grams saturated fat. Between the amount of cheese and meat, you’ve gone well above the daily fat limit.

Healthy Lasagna Tips:
  • Instead of fatty meats or sausage, use ground turkey, turkey sausage,veal, bison or 90-95% lean ground beef.
  • Trim down the fat and cholesterol by replacing part of the meat with beans or chopped mushrooms.
  • Choose whole wheat noodles.
  • Use mostly part-skim cheese and add just a sprinkle of fattier cheese (about 1-2 tablespoons per serving).
  • Pile on the veggies while holding back on some of the cheese and meat.
  • Watch those portions!
  • Check out more ways to lighten up your lasagna.
  • Squash and Spinach Lasagna
Mac & Cheese

Pros:

This classic favorite can provide a healthy dose of calcium, protein and fiber. To do so, use moderate portions of cheese and use whole grain pasta. If you think outside the mac & cheese box, you can even get in your veggies like winter squash, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes or cauliflower.

Cons:

Many traditional mac & cheese recipes can rack up 1,000 calories—that’s half your daily recommended calories! If you’re making the boxed version, you’re talking boatloads of sodium and a laundry list of added preservatives. Folks may also turn to nonfat cheese, which also has tons of chemicals and will leave you without tasty results.

Healthy Mac & Cheese Tips:
  • Experiment with whole grain pasta to up your fiber.
  • Add a veggie like in Ellie’s Macaroni and 4 Cheeses.
  • Use small portions of flavorful cheeses like sharp cheddar. Aim for 1-2 tablespoons per serving.
  • Serve mac & cheese as a side dish alongside lean protein and veggies.
  • Check out more lightened mac & cheese tips and recipes.
YOU VOTE: Who’s the winner? Lasagna or mac & cheese?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

Keep Reading

Next Up

Macaroni & Cheese, Lightened Up

I don’t know many people that would turn down mac and cheese. But is there a way to devour it without worry? Learn how to make the cheesy goodness with less calories and more flavor.

50 Mac and Cheese Recipes

Find dozens of new ways to make a weeknight favorite from Food Network Magazine.

Spicy Macaroni and Cheese — Meatless Monday

Upgrade your mac-and-cheese game with one key ingredient: cayenne pepper.

Mini Mac and 'Shrooms — Meatless Monday

Upgrade your macaroni-and-cheese game by adding hearty, earthy mushrooms with the help of Food Network Magazine's easy recipe.

Macaroni and Cheddar Cheese — Meatless Monday

For this Meatless Monday, delight in Food Network's Macaroni and Cheddar Cheese from Rachael Ray.

Make Irish Macaroni and Cheese

Just in time for St. Patrick’s Day, whip up this easy Irish Macaroni and Cheese from Food Network Magazine.

How to Make Fried Mac and Cheese

Once you’ve made your favorite mac and cheese from Food Network Magazine’s 50 Twists on Mac and Cheese (page 118, March issue), try this tasty trick for using up leftovers.

Spinach and Artichoke Macaroni and Cheese — Meatless Monday

Cozy up to winter comfort food without the calories using Food Network Kitchen's surprisingly healthy recipe for macaroni and cheese.

Lobster Mac & Cheese — Most Popular Pin of the Week

Ina Garten's Lobster Mac & Cheese is the ultimate comfort food. Here Ina adds decadent lobster meat to the classic recipe and tops it with crunchy breadcrumbs.

Creamy Jalapeno Popper Macaroni and Cheese — Meatless Monday

Two comfort foods collide in the ultimate mash-up for over-the-top flavor.