Which is Healthier, Potato Salad or Macaroni Salad?

Heading out to a backyard picnic? Which side should you choose, potato salad or macaroni salad?

Potato Salad

Pros:

Potatoes are loaded with nutrients including fiber, vitamin C and potassium – they’re also free of fat and cholesterol. No matter which recipe you choose, potatoes are often accompanied by good-for-you veggies and herbs like celery, onions, carrots, parsley, dill and basil.

Cons:

The addition of m ayonnaise, oily dressings and sometimes bacon will fatten up potato salad. You’re looking at over 420 calories and 30 grams of fat per cup.

Healthy Potato Salad Tips:
  • Cut the mayo in half and replace it with nonfat Greek yogurt.
  • Lose the mayo all together and use small portions of vinaigrette dressing.
  • Make your favorite recipe with sweet potatoes instead.
  • More tips and recipes for lightening up potato salad.
Macaroni Salad

Pros:

Pasta is a blank canvas for any flavors you like and there’s plenty of room for veggies and herbs.

Cons:

Once again, dressings are to blame; it’s easy for a cup of macaroni salad to top 600 calories and 40 grams of fat. Plus, classic macaroni salad dressings are often high in added sugars. One cup of cooked pasta has 200 calories all by itself.

Healthy Pasta Salad Tips:
  • Use whole-grain pasta to boost the fiber.
  • Just like potato salad you can lighten up the dressings with low-fat yogurt or vinaigrette.
  • The more veggies, the better.
  • More tips and recipes for lightening up macaroni salad.
Tell Us: Who's the winner? Potato or macaroni salad?
Keep Reading

Next Up

Which is Healthier, Lasagna or Mac & Cheese?

Our next head-to-head battle is between two popular pasta entrées. Who’ll win this (comfort) food fight, lasagna or macaroni and cheese?

Salad Bar Face-Off: Which Is Healthier?

Before you hit the salad bar, see how some popular ingredients compare.

POLL: Macaroni Salad or Potato Salad?

Which All-American classic salad do you prefer to eat -- macaroni salad or potato salad? Vote here.

Chicken Nuggets: Which Are Healthiest?

As a mom, I certainly understand the need to pop frozen nuggets into the oven. As a dietitian, I want to make sure those nuggets aren't filled with junk.

Which Airlines Have the Healthiest Food?

A new study fills flyers in on which airlines serve nutritious midflight meals and snacks, and which leave healthy eaters high and dry.

Breakfast Face-Off: Which is Healthier?

Food Network Magazine staged a breakfast face-off and asked a nutritionist to name the better choices. The results might surprise you.

Holiday Face-Off: Which is Healthier?

Food Network Magazine staged a holiday face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices for holiday baking ingredients.

Thanksgiving Face-Off: Which is Healthier?

Food Network Magazine staged a Thanksgiving face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices. Here's how some staples compare.

Which is Healthier: Pumpkin or Pecan Pie?

These super popular Thanksgiving desserts are going head to head and the competition is fierce. Which gets your vote?

How to Build a Healthier Potato Salad

Traditional versions of potato salad are drowning in gobs of full-fat mayonnaise. Let the flavor of this tuber shine by making a lightened-up potato salad using these simple steps.