Taste Test: Chewy Chocolate Chip Granola Bars

There are so many brands of this lunch box classic. Which is best for snacking?
granola bars
There are so many brands of this lunch-box classic. Which is best for snacking?
Nutrition

There’s a wide range of granola bar options and an even broader range of ingredients. Some brands do a much better job of making their bars with quality stuff. They all contain some form of sugar (they wouldn’t taste very good without it), but we looked at all the ingredients very carefully to evaluate the best options.

The Criteria

For this taste test, we rated chewy chocolate chip bars on taste, ingredients and nutritional information—focusing on calories, fat and sugar. We rated each on a 5-point scale (5 being the highest).

Rating: 4
Cost: $0.78 per bar

Nutrition Info (35 gram bar): 140 calories; 3.5 grams of fat; 12 grams of sugar

Our Take: A nice looking ingredient list, ample chocolate chips and a super chewy (almost too chewy) texture. Sweetened with brown rice syrup, sugar, dextrose and barely malt extract, there was plenty of sweet chewiness in this bar.

Rating: 3
Cost: $ 0.52 per bar

Nutrition Info (24 gram bar): 100 calories; 3 grams of fat; 7 grams of sugar

Our Take: Honestly, these taste good, but the quality of ingredients leaves a lot to be desired. They had nice texture, but were VERY sweet and contain lots of highly processed ingredients.

Rating: 2
Cost: $ 0.77 per bar

Nutrition Info (28 gram bar): 120 calories; 3.5 grams of fat; 6 grams of sugar

Our Take: These bars tasted flat and stale with virtually no chocolate chips to be found. Made with healthy oils and ingredients that looked good on paper; I love many Annie’s products but this bar was disappointing.

Rating: 3.5
Cost: $0.96 per bar

Nutrition Info (35 gram bar): 140 calories; 4.5 grams of fat; 11 grams of sugar

Our Take: These babies were highest in fat thanks to the addition of dried coconut and coconut flour, but there was no outward coconut flavor. Coconut is actually a common ingredient in granola, so it's often found in granola bars. This was the priciest bar tested and they were sweetened with mostly evaporated cane juice, invert cane syrup and molasses. They had nice chew but not enough chips.

Rating: 4.5
Cost: $0.27 per bar

Nutrition Info (30 gram bar): 140 calories; 5 grams of fat; 9 grams of sugar

Our Take: Perfectly sized for little hands, these bars were the yummiest of the bunch. They had wonderfully chewy texture and were filled with chocolate chips. No shortage of added sweeteners here (sugar, coconut, molasses and corn syrup), but they didn't taste overly sweet.

Rating: 1
Cost: $0.60 per bar

Nutrition Info (28 grams bar): 100 calories;  3 grams of fat; 8 grams of sugar

Our Take: Not a fan of these overly sweet and highly processed bars. The first ingredient is chicory root, a “faux fiber” used to boost the fiber content. The markings on the box suggest “good for the whole family” but I wouldn’t give these to my kids.

Honorable Mention

We left these guys out because the dried cherries made them too different from the others we tested, but they are yummy. A decent ingredient list, great texture, and lots of chocolate chips  - a delish choice.

Tell Us: What’s your favorite chewy chocolate chip granola bar?

Next Up

Taste Test: Jarred Spaghetti Sauce

Sometimes there’s no time to whip up a batch of homemade tomato sauce. We checked out some of the popular supermarket tomato sauces -- Rao's, Newman's Own, Trader Joe's, Prego and Barilla -- to see how they measured up.

Miller High Life Makes an Ice Cream Bar That Tastes Like Dive Bars

In collaboration with Tipsy Scoop, the treat includes a peanut swirl to mimic peanut shells always found on dive bar floors as well as a hint of tobacco smoke flavor.

Doritos Launches a Line of Dips That Taste Like Your Favorite Chip Flavors

The Spicy Nacho and Cool Ranch Jalapeno dips can also be paired with pizza, pretzels, vegetables, wings and more.

Starbucks’ New Valentine’s Day Drinks Taste Like Your Favorite Chocolate Treats

One tastes like chocolate-covered strawberries, and the other chocolate hazelnut.

Lindt Launches a Line of Oat Milk Chocolate Bars

The non-dairy "classic recipe" milk chocolate bars are plant-based and made with gluten-free oats.

Halwa Tastes Like Sweet Nostalgia

As a child, I used to bite my grandmother’s shoulder until I got a fresh batch of halwa. Now, I prepare it every Diwali.

28 Seriously Delicious Chocolate Chip Cookies You Can Order Online

We found the best chocolate chip cookies no matter what your taste.

The Secret Ingredient That Makes These Cookies Extra Chewy

OK — it's beans! But not in the way you think.