Which is Healthier: Pumpkin or Pecan Pie?

These super popular Thanksgiving desserts are going head to head and the competition is fierce. Which gets your vote?

Photo by: Tara Donne ©Food Network

Tara Donne, Food Network

These super-popular Thanksgiving desserts are going head to head. With both having single pie crusts and packed with good-for-you ingredients, the competition is fierce. Which gets your vote?
Pumpkin Pie

Pros:

According to the USDA’s Dietary Guidelines for Americans, we should all be eating 2 cups of orange veggies each week. Pumpkin pie can help meet these recommendations plus that brilliant orange color provides the antioxidants vitamin A and lutein.

Cons:

Fatty ingredients like traditional pastry crust, butter, cream cheese, half-and-half, or shortening can sabotage the nutritional value. Mountains of sugar from canned pumpkin pie filling and spoonfuls of sugary toppings can also send calories through the roof. Topped with whipped cream or a la mode, a slice can weigh in at close to 500 calories.

Healthy Pumpkin Pie Tips:
  • Use gingersnap cookies for a lighter crust made without partially hydrogenated oils or make your own canola oil pie crust.
  • No need for mounds of sugar—let the sweetness of the pumpkin take over.
  • Steer clear of sugary or heavily-sweetened pumpkin pie filling. The canned pumpkin puree should have one ingredient; add your own spices from there.
  • Serve with one heaping spoon of freshly made whipped cream and fresh fruit like apples, oranges and pears.
  • Try Food Network Kitchens slimmed version.
Pecan Pie

Pros:

One ounce (about 19 halves) of pecans has 195 calories, 20 grams of fat, and 3 grams of fiber. It provides two-thirds of your daily recommended amount of manganese, an essential mineral that help with blood clotting and helps form bones, connective tissue, and sex hormones. It’s also a good source of thiamin and copper. Studies have found that pecans can help reduce your bad (LDL) cholesterol and total cholesterol.

Cons:

Pecan pie is traditionally made with a good amount corn syrup and/or brown sugar, which only contributes sugar and calories. Once again, your crust can be a big source of fat, especially artery-clogging saturated fat. Although pecans have many healthy attributes, more doesn’t mean it’s healthier. Mounds of pecans can contribute to high calories and fat in a pecan pie.

Traditionally prepared pecan pie has about 550 calories. With ½ cup vanilla ice cream, the calories go up to 700. That’s 35% of your recommended daily calories just for dessert.

Healthy Pecan Pie Tips:
  • Make your own healthier pie crust.
  • Use half the amount of sugary ingredients like corn syrup, maple syrup, or sugar.
  • If you need to go a la mode, use a light vanilla frozen yogurt or low fat ice cream.
YOU VOTE: Who’s the winner? Pumpkin pie or pecan pie?
Keep Reading

Next Up

10 Healthy Thanksgiving Desserts

Planning your turkey day menu? We’ve got something for every kind of sweet tooth, filled with fall flavors.

Best 5 Thanksgiving Desserts

Check out Food Network's top-five Thanksgiving desserts to find recipes for family-friendly sweets from Giada, Alton, Sunny and more Food Network chefs.

Best 5 Thanksgiving Desserts

This Thanksgiving, look no further than Food Network's best Thanksgiving desserts for classic recipes to serve as the perfect ending to your meal.

Thanksgiving Desserts: Something for Everyone

Cooking for a crowd this holiday? Stumped by how to accommodate family members with special dietary needs? We’ve got sweet ideas for everyone.

Make and Freeze Pie Dough — Thanksgiving Tip of the Day

If you're using homemade pie crusts, make the dough now and freeze it in freezer bags for Thanksgiving.

Thickening Fruit Pies — Thanksgiving Tip of the Day

When thickening a fruit pie filling, there are several options to consider. Very often flour or cornstarch is used, but in certain instances tapioca, arrowroot and potato starch can also help achieve the desired consistency.

On TV

Food Network Apps

In the Kitchen

Get over 70,000 FN recipes on all your mobile devices.

Facebook Messenger

Ask our bot for recipes, meal ideas and daily food trivia.

Amazon Echo

Just say "Alexa, enable Food Network skill" to get started.