Which is Healthier: Burger vs. Hot Dog

In this new series, we’re pitting some of your favorite foods against each other. We’re starting out with the hottest fight of the barbecue season: burger verses hot dog. Who’s the winner of this battle?
In this new series, we’re pitting some of your favorite foods against each other. We’re starting out with the hottest fight of the barbecue season: burger verses hot dog. Who’s the winner of this battle?
Burger

Pros:

Burgers aren’t about ground beef anymore. Although you can make a killer burger from 90 to 95% lean ground beef, burger alternatives like turkey, bison, ostrich, and fish are delicious too. These leaner choices provide tons of protein, iron and energy boosting B-vitamins.

Cons:

It’s easy to rack up the calories with huge burger patties, tons of cheese and other fatty toppings, mayo and other calorie-laden condiments and huge buns. Ground beef and other ground up proteins are also at higher risk for food bugs like E. Coli.

Healthy Burger Tips:
  • Opt for leaner meats like 90 to 95 percent lean ground beef, bison, or turkey breast. If lighter options aren’t available, then mind your portions (aim for 3 to 4 ounce patties).
  • Pile burger high with veggies like fresh lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
  • Be mindful of sauces—use 1 to 2 tablespoons to control portions.
  • Choose high fat toppers like cheese, mayo, avocado and fried onions sparingly.
  • More ways to lighten up burgers
  • Healthy burger recipes
Hot Dog

Pros:

Hot dogs aren’t only an adult favorite, kids love them too. I always know I can get my kids to eat a ho tdog when we head out to a barbecue. The calories aren’t out of control -- a regular sized (1.6 ounce) hot dog with a touch of ketchup, mustard and a bun only has a few hundred calories.

Cons:

These bad boys are highly processed and most brands contain nitrites. Most folks don’t stop at just one—they eat 2 or 3 hotdogs at one sitting—not to mention the mayonnaise-laden sides and other barbecue goodies that get gobbled up too.

Hot dogs have also been linked to the bacteria Listeria Monocytogenes, shown to effect the very young and old.

Healthy Hot Dog Tips:
  • A variety of hot dogs are available such as nitrate-free or reduced fat.
  • If you need a second dog, hold back on the bun or the mayonnaise-filled side salads.
  • Sauerkraut is a low calorie topping for hot dogs that can help fill you up, though it’s high in sodium.
YOU VOTE: Who’s the winner? Burger or hot dog?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

You Might Also Like:

Keep Reading

Next Up

Which is Healthier: Fruit Cobbler vs. Fruit Pie

Summer is all about fruit-filled desserts. When faced with the choice of cobbler or pie, which would you choose? Read the pros and cons of each and YOU vote for the healthier winner!

Taste Test: Which Hot Dogs Are the Top Dogs?

Grilling season is in full swing so we’ve vetted the most popular brands out there to see which dogs should you be tossing on the barbecue.

VOTE: Star vs. Chopped Hot Dog Showdown

This week, Star Season 7 winner Jeff Mauro and Chopped judge Scott Conant and grilling up their best hot dogs. Both chefs beef up their grilled dogs with over-the-top toppings – so whose will you serve up?

5 Healthier Hot Dogs

I used to be totally against anything related to a hot dog. Part of the reason I changed my mind was because of these healthier options.

Katie's Healthy Bites: Healthier Hot Dogs

Can you eat hot dogs on a healthy diet? Here are our picks for the best brands and the most filling hot dog toppings.

Burgers vs. Ribs: Which Gets Your Vote (and Bite) at the Barbecue?

Cast your vote to tell FN Dish which of these meaty bites is your ultimate cookbook favorite.

How Do You Top Your Hot Dog? Rachael vs. Guy: Celebrity Cook-Off

Inspired by Episode 4 of Food Network's "Rachael vs. Guy: Celebrity Cook-Off," how do you top your hot dog?

5 Healthy Ways to Dress Your Hot Dog

Get creative and healthy ways to dress up your hot dog.