Food Fight: Eggnog vs. Hot Cocoa

'Tis the season for eggnog and hot chocolate. Find out which is the most sensible choice – it all comes down to how you make it.

Are these sippers on your holiday hit list? Find out which is the most sensible choice – it all comes down to how you make it.

Eggnog

A frothy combo of egg, cream and sugar, this classic libation is a gut-buster. Add a jolly splash (or two) of booze and the calories only get worse.

Homemade and lightened-up versions can dial back the fat and calories and highlight the healthy attributes of this seasonal treat. Use lower fat ingredients and eggnog has a lot to offer – namely good-for-you nutrients like protein, calcium and vitamin D.

Hot Cocoa

Like eggnog, homemade hot cocoa has quite a bit to offer in the nutrition department. If your favorite recipe is made with unsweetened cocoa powder, you’ll get a merry dose cell-protecting antioxidants. Finished off with warmed milk and a hint of sugar, the calories in each mug stay reasonable.

Versions made with higher fat dairy like cream or half-and-half, plus melted hunks of chocolate are another story. If only the real thing will do, opt for a small amount of dark chocolate – it will give big flavor for a modest amount of calories. Chocolate also boasts vitamins, minerals and a touch of healthy fat.

Again, nutrients like protein, calcium and vitamin D are the big winners in this cozy beverage.

If your top pick is hot cocoa mix, see the results of our taste test.

Healthy Eats Winner: Hot cocoa pulls ahead of egg nog for being lower in fat, plus the benefit of all those antioxidants.

TELL US: Which gets your vote: egg nog or hot cocoa?
Keep Reading

Next Up

Carolina vs. Colorado: Regional Food Fight

Super Bowl 50 pits a Southeastern barbecue powerhouse against a Colorado city known for stellar Mexican food and microbrews, promising a fierce battle on the food front.

Food Fight! Lemonade vs. Iced Tea

Looking to quench your thirst with one of these summertime classics? First, check out which drink came out on top in this battle of the beverages.

Food Fight!: Pasta vs. Pizza

These two Italian delights are going head-to-head! See which mouthwatering favorite will come out on top.

Food Fight: Beer vs. Liquor

Labor Day is around the corner—should you grab an ice cold beer or choose a spirits-filled cocktail? This battle is a tricky one…

Food Fight!: Tofu vs. Tempeh

Do you turn to tofu or tempeh as a meatless protein option? Find out which is the healthier choice.