Made with the family’s own dark syrup and a flaky lard-and-butter crust according to Kate McDonald Beattie’s original recipe, the maple cream pie at The Creamery Restaurant has not changed in nearly half a century. In fact, Beattie herself made the pies, topping slices of rich maple-sweetened custard with freshly whipped cream, until she was in her early 90s. One of her daughters is the current pie maker for the family-owned restaurant, which serves homey fare in an 1891 building that was once the local creamery.
Special Dish: Maple Cream Pie
Seen an error? Report This Listing
Make restaurant favorites at home with copycat recipes from FN Magazine.
Let Guy take you on a coast-to-coast tour Friday at 9|8c.