Star Scrapbook: Donna Sonkin Shaw Save Collection Share Donna Sonkin Shaw was the first finalist eliminated on Food Network Star, Season 10. Relive the memorable moments from her time on the show. 1 / 11 Photo: Eddy Chen © All About Donna A health coach from New York City, Donna was the first finalist sent home from the Season 10 competition. Despite her strong point of view — healthy takes on classic recipes — Donna struggled to make a connection with the mentors in just one week.