Star Scrapbook: Kara Sigle Save Collection Share Flip through a Food Network Star finalist's scrapbook for an up-close-and-personal look at journal entries. 1 / 14 Photo: Todd Plitt © Team Bobby's First Farewell In Episode 2, caterer and fitness guru Kara Sigle was the first member of Team Bobby to be eliminated. Bobby wished he'd had more time to "pull the star out" of her.