Find the Restaurants Featured on Guilty Pleasures: Coast-to-Coast Indulgences

There's no escaping the decadence of these rich dishes, including next-level mac and cheese with lobster.

Maple Street Biscuit Company

For Amanda Freitag, it's all about The Squawking Goat at Maple Street Biscuit Company in Jacksonville, Fla. Not only is there a golden fried chicken breast and melty goat cheese sandwiched in the middle of a buttery buttermilk biscuit, but there's also a bold jalapeno-studded jelly. "If you were me, you're guilty of getting messy," Amanda explains of approaching this next-level plate.

Where to Find: Maple Street Biscuit Company

Slater's 50/50

"See, I love bacon, and at Slater's 50/50 you can pretty much get bacon in everything," Alfonso Ribeiro says of the scene at this Pasadena, Calif., hot spot. When he visits, he opts for the Bacon Brownie, a double-stacked brownie tower featuring smears of gooey chocolate ganache and plenty of crumbled, crispy, brown sugar-laced bacon. "It's like a mouthful of flavors and textures all together," Alfonso adds.

Where to Find: Slater's 50/50

The Atlantic ChipShop

Homemade buns, crisped mushy peas, fresh halibut, french fries and a drizzle of gravy — it all comes together to create a reinvented take on a British classic, the butty, at The Atlantic ChipShop in New York. "That's good stuff," Madison Cowan notes simply of this Fish & Chip Butty.

Where to Find: The Atlantic ChipShop

Catch New York

"Lobster is guilty on its own … dipped in butter. Mac and cheese is guilty on its own. When you put the two together, it's like double the guilty," Tia Mowry says of the Macaroni & Lobster Cream she orders at Catch New York in the Big Apple. Featuring a combination of claw and tail lobster meat, a silky cream sauce and cool mascarpone cheese, this decadent dish is finished with breadcrumbs and quickly baked before serving.

Where to Find: Catch New York

Lincoln Restaurant

Just when you think there's no way to reinvent a classic apple pie, Lincoln Restaurant in Portland, Ore., shows off its Bacon Apple Pie, featuring a traditional pastry crust, tender apple filling and — wait for it — an all-bacon blanket on top. "It's almost one of those dishes that you can't believe hasn't always existed," Gail Simmons says, "and now, quite frankly, it's difficult to eat apple pie without a lattice of bacon."  

Where to Find: Lincoln Restaurant

White House Sub Shop

Take it from Guy Fieri: "This sub is an Atlantic City original." He's talking about the Italian Sub at White House Sub Shop in Atlantic City, N.J. There's no shortage of fixings inside this 18-inch beauty. It's stuffed with provolone cheese, two kinds of salami and a layer of capicola, plus fresh veggies like lettuce, tomatoes and onion. 

Where to Find: White House Sub Shop

Want More Guilty Pleasures?

Check out the Guilty Pleasures headquarters for more restaurant guides, then take a quiz to see if we can guess your guilty pleasure.

More: Guilty Pleasures

More from:

Guilty Pleasures