A Boys vs. Girls Dinner Battle, and Why It's Not About Being "Thesaurus Rex" — Jeff's Star Report

Hear from past Food Network Star winner Jeff as he breaks down the third episode in hilarious fashion.
Related To:

Finalists Alex McCoy, Jay Ducote, Eddie Jackson, Dom Tesoriero and Arnold Myint talk with Guest Judges Geoffrey Zakarian, Sunny Anderson and Selection Committee Giada de Laurentiis and Bobby Flay during the Star Challenge, Trendy Dinner, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

This week is all about trends, so the finalists' first challenge is to craft a dish that is both delicious and camera ready. Photographing food and food styling are often-overlooked skills that usually require the work of several experienced and talented professionals. Thanks to social media, however, we have all become food stylists and photographers, snapping pics of every malt ball, pretzel rod and airport kiosk sandwich we shove down our gullets. I'm 100 percent guilty of this as well and make no apologies, but oftentimes, the photos do not do the food justice (mine included). Regardless, I love this trend, and it only connects us more to the magic and allure of food. But I digress ...

And they’re off! Emilia is a bat out of hell, Rosa is frying meatballs, Dom is icing his pesto, Eddie is contrasting, and Big Jay is tasting the rainbow. Arnold is not worried one iota because he plates like Picassette (Picasso’s drag queen alter ego). Sandwich man Alex makes that classic mistake of “plopping on the top bun.” I would have halved the sandwich and exposed the colorful interior structure. In my opinion, that makes for a much better sandwich photo.

Finalist Rosa Graziano taking a picture of her dish, Polpettine di Carne, for the Mentor Challenge, Tiny Foods, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

They snap some foodie pics on a tiny 3G phone and go to present — but wait! Curve Ball Bobby throws the gang a little chin music and informs the finalists that he and Giada will be tasting only eight out of the 10 dishes, choosing those eight based solely on visual appeal. And first up to bat:

Eddie: "Invincible" Eddie’s pretty scallop shot won over G & B. Flavors are on point, but what’s a "mojo," bro?! Next rule in my ever-expanding list of the Rules of Food Network Star:

Rule No. 10: Always assume your audience doesn’t know what the hell you just cooked. Your viewers most likely did not attend culinary school or work the line at an Asian-fusion gastropub. They surely don’t spend eight hours a day googling “best mojo recipes for scallops.” Be specific and, sometimes, overly informative.

Jay: Backstory, good flavor, less rehearsed.

Dom: Madone! Looks like someone hit the spa last night for a hot stone massage and loosened up a bit.

Arnold: Once again, his plate is a virtual cornucopia of sunshine, feathers and glitter lasers. Unfortunately, his presentation is bland. To me, he looks tired, which is an unfortunate byproduct of competing on a reality show. It is truly an exhausting experience, and sometimes you just need a nap. When I competed on Food Network Star, I was so tired at times that I wanted to be sick.

Finalist Michelle Karam in evaluations for the Mentor Challenge, Tiny Foods, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Michelle: Food first, story second. It’s Week 3, people!

Rosa: See my rule from last week regarding talking about the food.

Sita: Dry chicken and missing sauce does not make good presentation.

Emilia: She gets a “lotta ripped” with her girlfriends on Fridays. Noted.

Alex: You. Got. Bunned.

Rue: Aesthetically unpleasant eggplant led to tears. Not sure if that’s a haiku, but I’m sticking with it.

And the winner of this first challenge is ...

Finalists Emilia Cirker, Sita Lewis, Eddie Jackson, Dom Tesoriero, Jay Ducote, Rosa Graziano and Arnold Myint in evaluations for the Mentor Challenge, Tiny Foods, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

NOOCH! Dom gets an advantage in the next challenge, and guess who walks in?

GZ and Sunshine. That’s right, my sister from another mister and daddy from another fatty: Geoffrey Zakarian and Sunny Anderson. We spend a lot of time together on set of our show The Kitchen, so I’m excited to see what they think of the finalists.

They lay out the next challenge, which is all about anti-comfort food trends — basically burnt, stinky, slimy stuff. They are challenged with providing a palatable raw appetizer, a slimy soup, a burnt salad, a stinky entree and an incendiary dessert. Dom is unaware of the word “incendiary” and I can bet he is not alone. It’s the gang’s first team challenge and Dom gets first pick of the teams. He immediately chooses boys versus girls. I smell the boys on the bottom. If I’m correct, it will be quite "incidiery" (sic).

They start planning immediately, as they have only 45 minutes to execute. The ladies band together quickly and agree that they must sell some sultriness. On the men’s team, per every competitive cooking show ever, nobody wants to make dessert. The cooking begins and the confidence is way up on both sides. We’re reminded 14 times that Eddie is indeed a huge fan of burnt citrus, Dom is riding the lightning after a successful first round with a double blue-veined stank fest, Rue is foolishly plating what looks like chunky tar on top of hot bone marrow, Rosa is charring fennel, and Michelle has overfilled the food processor with her spinach "sloup" (slimy soup) leading to near-disastrous results. Jay’s got a young gumbo, Emilia has flamed meringue and Arnold loves lipstick. Time’s up, hands up.

Guest Judges Geoffrey Zakarian and Sunny Anderson during the Star Challenge, Trendy Dinner, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Here’s the breakdown.

Rue: Hopefully her sultry delivery outshined her warm tar tar.

Michelle: I was raised on eggplant tentacles, so I totally get what she’s saying. It is by far the most-tender part of the eggplant, next to eggplant testicles (of course).

Finalists Michelle Karam, Rosa Graziano and Sita Lewis talking to the Selection Committee about their dishes during the Star Challenge, Trendy Dinner, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Rosa: Sunny’s face says it all, and GZ is having too much fun with his maritime puns. The charred fennel is too fibrous, and judging by the amplified sound of the judges chewing this salad, I agree.

Sita: Her food falls flat and in a Food Network Star first, her food is dubbed not nearly stinky enough. Her presentation is repetitive and lackluster. She hearts and souls the judges to death.

Emilia: Nailed the presentation and her creative dessert. Well done!

Onto the boys:

Alex: He failed to make a sandwich and the judges didn’t seem to notice. They did, however, notice his mediocre presentation.

Finalists Arnold Myint, Eddie Jackson, Jay Ducote and Alex McCoy preparing their dishes during the Star Challenge, Trendy Dinner, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Jay: Nailed the presentation, but his murky gumbo fell short — but he knew that. He should have made what he wanted, not what Dom told him to make. Next rule!

Rule No. 11: In group challenges, trust your gut. Don’t let the others persuade you to go against your instinct.

Eddie: Ruh roh. Eddie blew it. He “um’d” the hell out of that presentation. Is he going home? I doubt it. The guy has been moving chains since Day One and he still is a judge favorite.

Dom: Dom’s stank chicken won over the judges, but they did pick up on some of his nervousness as he tried to book it out of there as quickly as possible.

Arnold: If "incendiary" is not trending right now on Google, Twitter and MyFacePage.net, then I hereby pledge to cancel my subscription to the Internet.

The boys wrapped it up quite well: a couple stumbles, but nothing major. Lack of vocabulary is not a valid reason to send anyone packing. This competition is about cooking on camera and not about being a "Thesaurus Rex."

Elimination time:

Guest Judges Geoffrey Zakarian, Sunny Anderson and Selection Committee Giada de Laurentiis and Bobby Flay in deliberation, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

The ladies are up first. Rue’s story was too long and she never talked about her unique African fare; Michelle slimed the judges in a good way with her spinach/octopi "sloup"; and Rosa’s lackluster meatball rolled out the door. Unfortunately, Sita’s heart and soul did not smell like roses, and Emilia’s dessert nailed the challenge with a double dose of “incind” (not a word until now).

Next up: Team Bro, led by the increasingly confident Dom. Alex made the mistake of not exciting Sunny. Eddie, as foreshadowed, lost some yardage to a false start. Jay’s compromised gumbo was saved by a warm and fluid presentation. GZ loved Dom’s chicken but noticed his nerves. So which team left the judges satisfied, entertained and feeling trendy?
NEITHER!

Finalists Rosa Graziano and Sita Lewis in elimination, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 11.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen, 2015, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

I love a good double-looser decision. It’s anyone’s game now, and both teams are susceptible to the chopping block. The winners of this challenge are Arnold and Dom from the Men’s team, but the overall winner of the challenge was Michelle, deservedly so. Emilia, Rue, Jay and Alex are safe as well. Rosa, Sita and Eddie are the bottom three. Going home this week is ...

Sita. Valliant effort indeed. She had a great energy, and if given more time, she could have really honed her soul-Italian POV.

Keep Reading

Next Up

The Ins and Outs of Star Salvation, According to Its Co-Host, Plus Pilot Time with Rachael Ray — Jeff's Star Report

Hear from Food Network Star, Season 7 winner Jeff Mauro as he breaks down the tenth episode in hilarious fashion.

A First-Person Account of Being Judged by Bobby and Giada, Plus the Finalists to Watch — Alex's Star Report

Hear from Alex Guarnaschelli as she recaps the latest episode of Food Network Star.

"Dom Dust," Coolers Full of Capers and Holidays with the Stars — Jeff's Star Report

Hear from Food Network Star, Season 7 winner Jeff Mauro as he breaks down the eighth episode in hilarious fashion.

A Risky Roast and a Brick Wall Made of "Duck on the Regular" — Jeff's Star Report

Hear from Food Network Star, Season 7 winner Jeff Mauro as he breaks down the sixth episode in hilarious fashion.

Slap Fights, Homesickness and a Decision to Leave — Jeff's Star Report

Hear from Food Network Star, Season 7 winner Jeff Mauro as he breaks down the seventh episode in hilarious fashion.

It's Pilot Time with the Gold Standard for Food Network Star Success — Alex's Star Report

Hear from Alex Guarnaschelli as she recaps the latest episode of Food Network Star.

“You're a Beast:” Avoid This Phrase, and 6 Other Savvy Rules of Star — Jeff's Star Report

Food Network Star, Season 7 winner Jeff offers been-there-done-that commentary on last night's all-new episode.

Star Report: 7 Key Takeaways from Finalists' 5-Course Dinners

We're breaking down the ins and outs of the latest episode of Food Network Star, Season 13.

Love Bites, Hard: Turf and Surf, Tough and Stuff, and the Opportunity of a Lifetime — Jeff's Star Report

Hear from Food Network Star, Season 7 winner Jeff as he breaks down the fifth episode in hilarious fashion.