WATCH: When the Wheel Isn't Your Friend

Watch what happens when the Wheel of Mythicality dishes out oddball culinary combos on Food Network Star.

Guest Judges Rhett James McLaughlin and Charles Lincoln with Hosts Giada de Laurentiis and Bobby Flay during the reveal of the Star Challenge, Guest Starring on Good Mythical Morning, as seen on Food Network Star, Season 12.

Photo by: Eddy Chen ©2016, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved.

Eddy Chen, 2016, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved.

More Food Network Star

Food Pairings Gone Bad 03:42

Finalists discover what unlikely food pairings they must combine in a dish.

Let's be honest: There was pretty much no chance that Rhett and Link's Wheel of Mythicality was going to yield such friendly "Will It" combos as peanut butter and jelly or strawberries and cream on Sunday's latest episode of Food Network Star. But the pairings that resulted from a quick spin of this diabolical wheel turned out such shocking and oddball mash-ups that some finalists could hardly handle it. Kimchi and bread pudding, anyone? How about octopus and macaroni and cheese? Those were the combinations that Joy and Tregaye were saddled with, respectively — and they didn't take too kindly to them.

Click the play button on the video above to watch the pairings get dealt one spin at a time, and see how the competitors reacted to receiving these unexpected combinations.

Related Reading:
Tune in to Food Network Star on Sundays at 9|8c.
Keep Reading

Next Up

Pumpkin Season Isn't Over Yet

These delicious recipes will keep you cooking and baking with pumpkin through the fall.

Grape Jelly Isn't Just for Toast Anymore

Learn how to make Grape Jelly-Glazed Black Cod on this week's Chopped Dinner Challenge.

WATCH: Rob Cramps Damiano's Style

Sous Chef Rob turned into more of a burden than a blessing for Damiano as the duo worked to execute Damiano's elegant dessert on Food Network Star.

WATCH: Martita Makes an Entrance

See what happened when the winner of Comeback Kitchen shocked her fellow Food Network Star finalists with her unexpected entrance.

WATCH: Jernard Gets Uncivilized

Relive Jernard's wow-worthy performances.