Starring Roll: Justin Warner's Mashed Potato-Peanut Butter Candy

Justin Warner doesn't play by the rules. He eats jellyfish on Thanksgiving, serves cold-pizza terrine at his Brooklyn restaurant and writes rap songs about wine. But when Alton Brown, Giada De Laurentiis and Bobby Flay had to choose their teams of aspiring stars for the most recent season of Food Network Star, Justin's unconventional approach caught Alton's eye. Alton picked Justin for his group, and throughout the season Justin was a rebel, presenting wild combos like peanut butter–stuffed dates topped with seaweed. In the end, after 4.5 million viewers voted, Justin emerged as the winner. He says Alton's guidance made all the difference. "It was a true mentorship," Justin says. "Day one, Alton said, 'No apologies.' That's how you win."

Although Justin has been busy planning his new show (coming this fall), we managed to pull him aside for a quick Thanksgiving assignment: Come up with a fun new way to use leftover mashed potatoes. Justin took an old-fashioned candy idea and turned it on its head. Traditional mashed-potato candy is made with peanut butter, but Justin added umeboshi paste (Japanese plum paste) as a twist on peanut butter and jelly. Try the recipe (pictured after the jump).

Photo by: Kang Kim

Kang Kim

Keep Reading

Next Up

Thanksgiving Face-Off: Which is Healthier?

Food Network Magazine staged a Thanksgiving face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices. Here's how some staples compare.

Last-Minute Thanksgiving Tips from Bobby and Friends

Hear from Bobby and friends as they share good-to-know turkey day tips ahead of the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday.

Thanksgiving Dinner-Hopping Strategies

You can do a lot of damage by eating a full plate each time you visit a family member or friend on Thanksgiving. Here's how you can prevent stuffing yourself.

On the Road Eats: Thanksgiving-Inspired Restaurant Dishes

Hit the road to try out these top Thanksgiving restaurant dishes featured on Food Network.

7 Lighter Takes on Essential Thanksgiving Sides

These Thanksgiving sides are just as satisfying as the classic recipes you're used to, just with less sugar and fat.

Wine Will Keep Well; Buy It Early — Thanksgiving Tip of the Day

Should you drink red or white with turkey? Don't fret if you're new to wine, there's no wrong answer, but we've got some picks to get you started.

Alton Brown Talks Turkey Day and His 5-Star Turkey Recipe

Just in time for Thanksgiving, we caught up with Alton Brown and chatted about his plans for the upcoming food-focused holiday.

Save Your Oven Space: 8 Thanksgiving Dishes to Make on the Stove

When oven space is at a premium, stick with these stovetop picks.