Marble Lane Scores 2012 Sandwich Showdown Win

Related To:

Jeff Mauro and the Marble Lane Team at the 2012 Sandwich Showdown

©Alex Geana Photography

Alex Geana Photography

It was an afternoon fit for sandwich enthusiasts last weekend, as Jeff Mauro joined nearly 20 restaurants for a Sandwich Showdown at the New York City Wine & Food Festival. Food Network’s own Sandwich King hosted the deliciously competitive event, which pitted sandwich maker versus sandwich maker in a battle of between-bread creations. While classic deli sandwiches made an appearance at this all-you-can-eat extravaganza, the dressed-up sandwiches — those that combined toasted, buttered bread, beefy cuts of meat, gourmet cheese and more — stole the show.

While planning for Thanksgiving dinner probably hasn’t even begun for most of us, event sponsor Whole Foods Market embraced Turkey Day leftovers with its Thanksgiving panini. Tender fresh turkey, smooth potatoes, sweet-tart cranberry sauce and more traditional staples were layered on herbed bread, grilled until crunchy and topped with a light sage drizzle.

In a showing of timeless comfort, Little Muenster cooked up a classic pairing: grilled cheese and tomato soup. Stuffed with richly decadent Taleggio cheese and finely chopped mushrooms, and served with cheese-topped tomato soup, these weren’t the everyday sandwiches from your childhood.

Jeff Mauro at the 2012 Sandwich Showdown

©Alex Geana Photography

Alex Geana Photography

The Sandwich King brought his best brisket to the tasting, offering attendees a soft buttered roll filled with succulent braised beef, gooey melted cheese and bright, crunchy cabbage. While most other vendors offered mere two-bite portions of their plates du jour, Jeff handed out full-size sandwiches surely fit for a king.

At the end of the afternoon, the vote for the sandwich superstar was in the hands of the other winners of the day, the hundreds of guests who chowed down on the seemingly endless variety of sweet and savory creations. After a fierce competition, they crowned Marble Lane the 2012 Sandwich Showdown Champion. The New York-based eatery dished out Kobe Beef Patty Melts that consisted of not one but two juicy Kobe patties, soft and sweet caramelized onions, tender mushrooms, and a duo of white and yellow cheddar cheeses between thin-cut triangles of bread that, while buttery, were still deliciously crispy. Not only did Marble Lane snag sandwich-bragging rights for the next year, but the restaurant also won $5,000 for their charity of choice and the right to create a sandwich to be featured at Whole Foods Markets in New York City.

Want to host your own sandwich showdown at home? Check out Sandwich King Jeff Mauro’s best-ever sandwich recipes and find out his top five tips for building a better sandwich.

More from NYCWFF:

Photos courtesy of Alex Geana Photography

Next Up

4 Food Network Chefs Score Daytime Emmy Nominations

There's reason to celebrate tonight!

Food Network Magazine: December 2012 Recipe Index

139 holiday recipes, including 100 gifts for food lovers, 50 muffins, and a step-by-step guide to rainbow cookies

Food Network Magazine: April 2012 Recipe Index

122 no-fuss recipes, including barbecue chicken pizza, 50 grilled cheeses and rustic homemade gnocchi

Food Network Magazine: November 2012 Recipe Index

143 recipes (plus 35 side dishes!), including make-ahead breads, 50 easy appetizers, and an Iron Chef-worthy Thanksgiving spread

Food Network Magazine: March 2012 Recipe Index

108 new recipes, including chocolate-covered everything, 50 brownies and a spectacular chocolate dessert

Food Network Magazine: July/August 2012 Recipe Index

136 easy recipes, including step-by-step fried chicken, 50 fun milkshakes and all-American desserts

Food Network Magazine: June 2012 Recipe Index

126 summer recipes, including polish sausage sandwiches, 50 things to grill in foil and cool ice cream cakes.

Food Network Magazine: October 2012 Recipe Index

120 new recipes, including great soups and stews, Ina’s comfort classics, and a spooky vampire-themed menu.

Excellent Vegetarian Sandwich Ideas

Go beyond the meaty fillings.

Jeff Mauro's Favorite Sandwich Shops

The Kitchen cohost tells us where he gets his fix when he’s on the road.