Monster Cookies — The New Girl

Related To:

I consider myself to be a moderately adventurous eater and determined cook. I enjoy expanding my food horizons and working with new ingredients. Saffron, anchovies — bring it on. But I have to admit, every once in a while all I want is a cookie. Not a cookie with sea salt or cocoa nibs, but a simple cookie, filled with goodies that a 10-year-old would go crazy over. Enter Monster Cookies.

There are some spooky recipes out there for Halloween, but Monster Cookies are anything but scary (despite what their name implies). The whole process is beautifully simple: just stir, mix and set the timer. Don't be afraid of a kitchen mess because you'll only need one bowl. The cookies are filled with peanut butter, chocolate chips, M&M's and oats — a baking newbie can’t go wrong when it comes to flavor.

With Halloween just around the corner, now's the perfect time to whip together a fresh batch. They're not particularly sophisticated nor will they get you to the Iron Chef Kitchen Stadium. But they're chewy, chocolatey and delicious. Ghosts and witches, young and old, will sing your praises.

Here are a few things to consider before making this recipe:

  • There is no flour in these cookies — you didn't read wrong.
  • Listen to Paula and don't overbake the cookies (8-10 minutes tops). They won't change color much and if you keep them in the oven for too long, they become tough.
  • If you somehow don't use up the whole 3 dozen cookies within a couple days, I suggest popping a few in the freezer to enjoy with ice cream throughout the week.
Keep Reading

Next Up

How to Host a Holiday Cookie Swap

This holiday season, get in the spirit with a party concept that'll satisfy every guest's sweet tooth and spread wintry cheer.

Holiday Treats: 50 Cookies

Turn your kitchen into Santa's workshop with dozens of recipes from Food Network Magazine.

5 Fan-Favorite Holiday Cookies Worth Preheating Your Oven — Fall Fest

Feast your eyes on these tried-and-true, fan-favorite cookie recipes, each bringing dozens of 5-star fan reviews to the plate.

Healthier Holiday Cookies

There are many ways to go about holiday cookie-making without gobs of butter and sugar—really, there are! Here are some ways to indulge sensibly.

Food Network Magazine's Holiday Cookie Survey

Vote to help provide Food Network Magazine with valuable insight on the sweetest part of December: cookies.

Giada’s Holiday Biscotti — 12 Days of Cookies

These light and crunchy Italian biscotti get their famed crispiness from a double baking process. Get Giada's recipe.

Melissa’s Delicate Mint Sandwich Holiday Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Melissa nestles a cool mint-butter filling between two tangy cream-cheese based sugar cookies and dusts them with fine colored sugar.

Cake Mix Holiday Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Use moist yellow cake mix to replace some of the usual ingredients in cookie batter to create soft holiday cookies.

No-Bake Chocolate Cookies to Ease Up the Holiday Cookie Swap

Ease up on your holiday prep (and on your oven) with simpler, no-bake cookies that'll disappear from the cookie swap just as quickly as any baked ones.