Could You Pick Your Favorite Beer Out of a Lineup?

Could You Pick Your Favorite Beer Out of a Lineup?

Are you particular about your beer? Loyal to a specific lager? Convinced your fave brand of beer is better than the other bottles or cans crowding the cooler? Many of us are. But do you think you could pick your preferred beer out of a lineup?

No problem, right? Don't be so sure. A recent study showed that, in blind taste tests, consumers actually have a hard time telling apart different brands of European pale lager, the most-commonly consumed style of beer around the world.

In a working paper for the American Association of Wine Economists published this month, authors Johan Almenberg, Anna Dreber and Robin Goldstein gave 138 adult beer drinkers, volunteers ages 21 to 70, three unlabeled samples of lager. Two of the lagers were the same product and one was different. The volunteers were asked to say which beer was not like the others. The test was repeated three times, so that each of three different European pale lagers widely available in the United States – Heineken (Netherlands), Stella Artois (Belgium) and Czechvar (Czech Republic) — could be the "singleton" beer with a shot at standing out between identical "twins."

And? People couldn't tell the difference.

"Our results suggest that when tasting blind, beer drinkers are unable to distinguish between different European lager brands," the researchers concluded.

Your lager brand loyalty, then, may have little to do with the taste (or look or smell) of the beer itself, but rather to how that beer is marketed. Yep, you probably just like the look of the label or bottle, or you relate to the brand identity some marketing genius has come up with, perhaps with someone just like you in mind.

Humbling, no? But, hey, cheer up. How 'bout a beer?

Watch Guy tour Kid Rock's brewery and taste test the American Light Lager by clicking the play button below.

Brewing American Light Lager 03:43

Guy tours Kid Rock's brewery and taste tests the American Light Lager.

Next Up

Chefs’ Picks: Favorite Movie Treats

When it comes time to watch the action unfold on the movie screen, even chefs who spend their days making masterful dishes prefer to cozy up with low-fuss snacks.

Chefs' Picks: Favorite Thanksgiving Sides

A few chefs from across the country share their favorite Thanksgiving side dishes, and the picks include a jazzed-up gravy and two ways to update seasonal sweet potatoes.

Fan-Favorite Finalists: Who's Your Pick?

Vote for your favorite Food Network Star finalist, then enter the sweepstakes for your chance to win prizes.

Chefs’ Picks: Favorite Big-Game Snacks

Five chefs from across the country share their must-have Super Bowl snacks.

Hamantaschen Cookies for Purim: Pick Your Favorite Filling

Learn about Hamantaschen cookies and the Jewish holiday of Purim. Plus vote on your favorite filling.

Takeout Fake-Out: Your Restaurant Favorites, Delivered

Check out Food Network's favorite takeout-inspired recipes, each a healthy option ready to eat in fewer than 30 minutes.

Chilled-Out Takes on Comfort Food Favorites

Some of our most beloved hot comfort food favorites have ice-cold, chilled-out alter egos that are well worth your time this summer.

#Patriotic: Our Favorite Healthy Instagram Picks for July 4th

Healthy Eats asked you to share your finest healthy patriotic treats on Instagram in honor of July 4th. Here are some of our red, white and blue favorites.

Fan Favorites: Your Picks for the Best. BBQ. Ever.

Find out what local hot spots fans go to for the best-ever barbecue.