The Pitfalls of the Cheap All-You-Can-Eat Buffet

The all-you-can-eat buffet tends to bring out the gourmand in all of us. But recently scientists have shed new light on the psychology of the all-you-can-eat buffet.
Various tasty and fresh food for banquet at hotel

Various tasty and fresh food for banquet at hotel

©Yuri Arcurs

Yuri Arcurs

The all-you-can-eat buffet tends to bring out the gourmand in all of us. It’s hard to rein yourself in when the only limit on what you can consume is the capacity of your own stomach and you have plunked down your money and are determined to get a good ROI. Even the most-virtuous eaters among us may find themselves making their way gingerly back to their tables clutching plates heaped precariously high – only to return to the buffet line for more, and maybe more than once.

We know this glinty-eyed gluttony from experience . (Oh, the shame! The shame!) But recently scientists have shed a revealing new light on the psychology of the all-you-can-eat buffet.

A study published in the Journal of Sensory Studies found that the amount diners paid for an all-you-can-eat (AYCE) buffet determined how good they thought the food tasted. Those who paid $4 for an Italian lunch buffet thought the pizza was “less tasty, less satisfactory and less enjoyable” than did those who paid $8 for the same buffet. What’s more, those who paid only $4 reported that the more they ate, the worse the food tasted, whereas those who paid $8 had no such sense of diminishing enjoyment.

“People set their expectation of taste partially based on the price – and it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy,” the study’s lead author, David R. Just, of Cornell University’s Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management, explained in The Atlantic. “If I didn’t pay much it can’t be that good. Moreover, each slice is worse than the last. People really ended up regretting choosing the buffet when it was cheap.”

In other words, while low prices may bring people in for an AYCE buffet, they may not entice them to come back and “may not be as profitable” for restaurants “in the long term,” Just’s team warned.

And there you have it – all you care to know about all you can eat.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Dining Out: All-You-Can-Eat Buffets

What’s not to love at those all-you-can-eat buffets? Well, the calorie overload, for one. I enjoy a big buffet as much as the next gal (especially in Vegas!), but there's nothing good about walking away overstuffed. Here are some tips for your next trip up to the buffet table.

Chicago's Best Cheap Eats

Track down Chicago's best food bargains, from breakfast through late-night snacks.

San Francisco's Best Cheap Eats

Check out some of the best under-$10 meals in San Francisco.

All-American Eats

This weekend, cook up a spread of all-American eats to celebrate the 4th of July. Food Network's patriotic menu boasts hot dogs, potato salad and blueberry pie.

Season's Eating! How to Navigate the Holiday Buffet

Here are some strategies to help you navigate any party spread.

Healthy Eating: All About Quinoa

Quinoa is full of protein, nutritious, easy to digest and gluten-free. Find out how to cook with quinoa with these tips from Food Network.

Yes, You Can Eat Avocado All Day

We’ve reached peak millennial.

Alex Eats: Peppers of All Kinds

Hot peppers can be tamed by removing the seeds and slicing the ribs off the interior flesh.

All the Ways to Eat Pumpkin Seeds

Whether or not you've been carving grinning pumpkins for your home's stoop, munching on pumpkin seeds is something you have to do this season.