Your Reusable Bag Made You Buy That Ice Cream (It's Not Your Fault!)

When consumers bring their own bags along to the supermarket, they tend to buy more organic produce — and more treats and snack foods, a study finds.
Your Reusable Bag Made You Buy That Ice Cream (It's Not Your Fault!)

You actually remember (for once!) to bring your reusable shopping bag with you to the market. With your environmental concerns front of mind, you stock up on organic fruits and veggies. Then, feeling virtuous and self-satisfied, you reward yourself with a container of your favorite ice cream or a big bag of chips.

Sound familiar? Scientists have spotted a trend: When consumers bring their own bags along to the supermarket, they tend to buy more organic produce — and more treats and snack foods.

Researchers at Harvard Business School and Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business, who published their findings in The Journal of Marketing, posit that two unconscious processes may be behind our reusable-bag-affected shopping proclivities.

Our tendency to buy more environmentally friendly products may be due to a “priming effect,” whereby one action prompts us to subsequently “behave in a congruent fashion.” (One good environmental turn deserves another.)

The less noble inclination to impulse-buy junk food, meanwhile, may be attributable to something called the “licensing effect,” meaning that when we do something admirable, we give ourselves license to do something less so.

“Previous research suggests that making a virtuous decision in one domain allows you to make an indulgence in a different domain,” study co-author Uma R. Karmarkar explained to The New York Times — like when you scarf down an entire sleeve of cookies because you deserve it after a long run.

Of course, none of us have any idea what she’s talking about. (Gulp.)
Photo courtesy of iStock

Next Up

7 Cheap Reusable Food Bags That You Can Buy Now

If you've been looking for a cheaper version of silicone food bags, we found affordable options.

3 Reusable Replacements for Zip-Top Plastic Bags

Skip the single-use plastic and store your snacks in these top-rated bags instead.

Brown-Bag Lunches Made Better — Meatless Monday

Celebrate Meatless Monday with satisfying sandwiches and salads with lunchtime-ready recipes from Food Network chefs.

Someone Has Made a Late-Night-Optimized Ice Cream

Nightfood is billed as a 'sleep-friendly' choice for midnight snackers.

Ice Cream Sundae Cupcakes

These party-perfect cupcakes look just like miniature sundaes, no ice cream needed!

What's Your Favorite Ice Cream?

Food Network Magazine is on a quest to find out how America eats ice cream.

Apple Fritter Ice Cream Sandwich

The Kitchen has a delicious serving idea for one of fall's favorite treats…the apple fritter. We're stepping things up with an Apple Fritter Ice Cream Sandwich.

Vegan Peppermint-Cookie Ice Cream

'Tis the season for all things peppermint! This vegan ice cream is rich and creamy (thanks to coconut milk) yet refreshingly cool from the pop of peppermint.

Ice Cream Politics: Party Flavors

Red states and blue states don't just disagree about politics—they take sides on ice cream flavors, too. Find out what Food Network Magazine uncovered.