This Pie Plate Is Going to Save My Thanksgiving

Let’s give thanks to the genius who invented it.

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these affiliate links.
November 08, 2018

Split-Decision Pie Plate, $13.95, Amazon

Split-Decision Pie Plate, $13.95, Amazon

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these links.

I’m in charge of dessert on Thanksgiving; I make all of the classics: apple, pecan, pumpkin and chocolate pies, and I make one new pie every year (last year it was banana cream, the year before that, butterscotch). But this year, much to my dismay, my family has asked that I tone it down — they’re trying to be healthy.

There’s been a loud, thrice-repeated request that we keep it to two pies. TWO PIES. Yes, this is enough dessert for a family of six. But two types of pie is not enough for a proper Thanksgiving! Should I make apple and pecan and skip the pumpkin? Uh, no. Pecan and pumpkin and no apple? Also, no. Do I ignore my family's wishes and make five pies anyway? Also, no, because I don’t want to be a jerk on Thanksgiving, which would also put me on the Christmas naughty list.

But guess what – some genius invented a pie plate that was basically made to solve my dilemma. The split decision pie pan, aka the everyone-gets-their-way-this-Thanksgiving pan, means that I can satisfy my family and myself this year. I can make a half pecan-half pumpkin, and a half apple-half banana cream pie this year, and everyone wins. And maybe my one new thing this year will be Thanksgiving cupcakes, because the fam just said to limit the pies — no one said anything about cupcakes.

Related Links:

Next Up

10 Le Creuset Gifts Any Food Lover Will Obsess Over

These swoon-worthy gifts are perfect for cooks of every level.

All the Thanksgiving Groceries You Should Buy at Costco

Buying in bulk is our secret Thanksgiving hack!

Where to Buy the Pioneer Woman's Instant Pot Online

Though many designs are sold out at Walmart, you can find refurbished models and other products online.

This $13 Tray Really Does Defrost Your Meat In Less Than an Hour

We put the rapid defroster to the test with frozen steak, chicken and salmon.

All Your Thanksgiving Dinner Questions — Answered!

Got a burning (ha!) question as you're prepping for Turkey Day? Don't worry — our experts have fast solutions to every puzzler.

This Coffeemaker Saves Me Nearly $100 a Month On Coffee

I'm actually sticking to my resolutions this year!

7 Picture-Perfect Sets of Family Christmas Pajamas

The dog pajamas (!!) are what's really getting us this year.

23 Valentine's Day Gifts Your Friends Will Love

Because your best friends deserve something sweet, too!

44 White Elephant Gifts Everyone Will Want to Trade For

Be the MVP of your gift exchange with these fun, food-themed gifts!

20 Best Food Gifts for Valentine's Day

From aromatic ice cream to charcuterie bouquets, these tasty treats are guaranteed to make your sweetheart swoon.

What's New