Mariah Carey/Marie Curie Birthday Cake Mix-Up Story Goes Viral

Woops!

On the face of it, Mariah Carey, the Grammy-winning singer, and Marie Curie, the Nobel prize-winning scientist, don’t have a whole lot in common, but their names apparently sound enough alike to be confused – and that fact has led to a viral moment.

Last week, a Toronto writer named Harriet Alida Lye tweeted out an image of a cake with a photograph of a somber-looking Marie Curie iced onto it, providing a sober counterpoint to a semicircle of pink frosted cupcakes decorated with candles spelling out “Happy Birthday.”

“Happy Birthday Siobhan,” read the white all-cap lettering on the cake. The lack of exclamation points, or really any punctuation, seemed to echo the unamused look on Curie’s face.

“My cousin in England told her colleagues she wanted a Mariah Carey birthday cake. They misunderstood, and is the cake they made her instead. It’s Marie Curie, looking very festive,” Lye captioned her post, which has generated almost 45,000 Retweets, more than 210,000 Likes, and 2,200 Comments, some of them quite clever.

“this cake deserves two Nobel prizes in different fields,” wrote one wag, referring to Curie’s status as the sole person to win Nobel prizes in two different sciences.

“Checking the replies to make sure no one beat me to the ‘she looks radiant!’ reply,” snarked another. (Curie, in case you have forgotten all your high school science, pioneered the theory of radioactivity.)

“It really ought to be a yellow cake...” quipped a third, making a uranium pun and prompting a self-identified “Pedantic Science bitch” to chide in response, “That’s uranium, not radium or polonium.”

Because, see, Curie discovered the elements polonium and radium, which are different from uranium (milled uranium oxide is also known as “yellowcake”) and these are words we never thought we would be typing in a story about Mariah Carey and birthday cake.

Carey, for her part, caught wind of the cake mix-up and responded with good cheer, retweeting Lye’s original post and commenting: “This could've been me if only I hadn't failed remedial math … happy birthday Siobhan!!”

Nice to see that Siobhan collected the exclamation points a birthday girl so richly deserves. However, the story has a coda: Lye’s cousin Siobhan Casey, whose birthday was actually back in March, clarified to the BBC that the cake was not a mistake on her colleagues’ part, but actually a deliberate joke.

Casey had once made a Mariah Carey cake for her brother, who is a big fan of the singer, but when she told a colleague about it, “he kept asking why I'd make a 'Marie Curie cake,'" she said. So another work pal, Elizabeth Kaye, decided to make her a Marie Curie cake for her birthday using what Kaye said was “the most sombre picture I could of Marie Curie.”

"It was hilarious, but a little embarrassing how far this has gone," Casey said of the way the whole thing blew up on social media and news reports.

Cake maker Kaye is embarrassed, too, but for different reasons. "I can't believe the worst, burnt cake I've ever baked has been seen by so many people -- including Mariah Carey," she told the BBC.

We are all our worst critics.

Related Links:

Keep Reading

Next Up

Texas Students’ Poster McPrank Goes Viral

They wanted to see Asians depicted on a poster at their local McDonald’s — so they made one and hung it up.

U.S. Coffee Consumption Goes Down, While Spending Goes Up

Thanks to the rise in single-cup pods, Americans are consuming less coffee — although they are also spending more on it than ever.

Comfort Food Mash-Ups, Remixed: Birthday Cake + Doughnuts

For this week’s remixed mash-up finale, we bring you two spectacular desserts that marry doughnuts not with croissants, but with a treat that’s even more festive: colorful confetti birthday cake.

Mix Up Your Onions

Hot tips from Food Network Kitchens' Katherine Alford: Keep red onions on hand: They're milder than yellow or white ones, so you can eat them raw.

Mix Up Your S'mores

For a riff on classic s'mores, try one of these pairings from The Kitchen.

Mix-and-Match Coffee Cake

Create your own coffee cake recipe: The possibilities are endless!

Bobby Flay Fit, Episode 3: Mix It Up

In Episode 3 of Food Network's Web series "Bobby Flay Fit," Chef Bobby Flay talks about the importance of trying new exercise routines.

5 Epic Cakes for a Summer Birthday

Our ridiculously delicious birthday cakes are perfect for celebrating. Whether you're going all-out with Ina's three-tiered hot pink cake or keeping it simple with a vanilla sheet cake with chocolate frosting, these desserts will elate any birthday boy or girl.