Magnolia Bakery's Banana Pudding Cookies Are Now On Amazon

Made famous by Sex and the City, the shop’s Banana Pudding is taking new form.

Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money off these affiliate links. Learn more.
March 22, 2023

Photo by: Photo courtesy of Magnolia Bakery

Photo courtesy of Magnolia Bakery

Editor's Note: Sex and the City streams on HBO Max. Food Network and HBO are both brands of parent company, Warner Bros. Discovery.

We’ve been clamoring for Magnolia Bakery since Sex and the City made it as popular as Cosmopolitans and Manolo Blahniks, but back then, it was only accessible to those who happened to live in close proximity to a New York City location. Over the years, Magnolia Bakery has expanded to further locations and online retail, but their latest expansion just might finally make it possible for everyone to get a taste.

Beginning March 22, Magnolia Bakery’s latest locations will be your grocery store aisles, as their Banana Pudding Cookies hit shelves and Amazon for the first time.

“Magnolia Bakery’s World-Famous Banana Pudding is one of the most recognized and iconic desserts in the U.S., known for the delicious combination of real bananas, creamy vanilla pudding and vanilla wafers. I knew translating these famous flavors into our new soft-baked cookie for grocery – made with real butter, bananas and chocolate – would result in an innovative new product for shoppers nationwide to try while being instantly recognizable as uniquely from Magnolia Bakery,” says Bobbie Lloyd, Chief Executive Officer of Magnolia Bakery.

These Banana Pudding Cookies are of course based on the legendary Magnolia Bakery banana pudding, but reimagined as a soft-based cookie. This cookie is as authentic in flavor as it can get, made with real butter, real bananas and real chocolate, and unlike the pudding, they are shelf stable. No need to stash in the fridge to keep fresh.

While a version of the Banana Pudding Cookies do exist at Magnolia’s bakeries, these are a whole new take on them, and will be available in a variety of flavors that include Classic Vanilla with White Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Chunk and Confetti with White Chocolate Chips.

“Our expansion into the grocery, and specifically the cookie aisle, allows Magnolia Bakery to expand our magic into more places for more consumers. We validated this through a recent brand study where nearly 70% of consumers shared they’d most like to see our brand expand to grocery store shelves next! We choose the cookie aisle as our first set after taking a strategic look at our most popular products and where our brand could elevate and grow a category with our retail partners,” says Eddie Revis, Chief Marketing Officer for Magnolia Bakery.

The new Banana Pudding Cookies will be found beginning March 22 at retailers across the U.S., including Fresh Market and Harris Teeter and solid as a four-pack of individually wrapped cookies with an MSRP of $7.99. They are also available to order on Amazon.

Related Content:

Next Up

Cotton Candy-Flavored Oreos Return This Summer

The nostalgic fan-favorite cookie flavor is back for the first time in almost a decade.

Subway Will Add Footlong Cookie, Permanently, to Menus Nationwide in 2024

But four lucky Subway locations will get a preview on December 4.

Oreo Releases What It’s Dubbing the ‘Most Oreo Oreo’

The creme filling has 'real Oreo grind' mixed into it, making it all very 'meta.'

There Will Be No New Cookies This Girl Scout Season

It’s time to put your orders in for all the classics.

Oreo’s New Cookie Will Take You to Outer Space

The limited-edition offering is stuffed with marshmallow-flavored "cosmic creme" and popping candies.

Snickerdoodle Oreos Are About To Be Your New Holiday Favorite

With snickerdoodle-flavor cookies and green-and-red-sugar-flecked cinnamon 'creme,' they blend the festive and the familiar.

What Is Cookie Butter?

Learn how to use it, store it and make your own.

How to Freeze Cookies and Cookie Dough

Plus precisely how to thaw and bake them.

How to Keep Cookies Soft

Plus, how to revive cookies that have turned hard (yep, it's possible).

What's New