Martha Stewart Changed the Way I Make My Sugar Cookies

Turns out, I've been doing it wrong for years.

December 17, 2019
Related To:

Get The All-New Food Network Kitchen App

Download Food Network Kitchen now to sign up and take advantage of the latest offer and get 40+ live classes a week, hundreds of on-demand cooking classes, in-app grocery ordering and so much more.

In this series, we're showing off some of the coolest recipes, tips and tricks we've learned from chefs in the all-new Food Network Kitchen app.

Sugar cookies are a big hit in my family; we make dozens of them every holiday season for gifts and dessert tables. But year after year, I find myself with the same conundrum — my sugar cookies come out looking okay but the texture is that of a thick rubber band. On top of that, my decorating skills are anything but impressive. I’m lucky if I can color in the lines, let alone outline and properly flood a traditional sugar cookie. The cookie struggle is real, folks.

This year I’m determined to nail holiday cookies. I decided to look to the Food Network Kitchen app to see if I could find the perfect sugar cookie recipe that tastes delicious and has festive flare. As expected, Martha Stewart came to my rescue. Her class on Embellished Wreaths takes the traditional sugar cookie up a notch (or two)! While taking the class, I realized that I had been making a big mistake with my sugar cookies wrong my entire adult life.

It’s such a minor mishap, but it creates a huge impact on your final bake: order matters. Most of the time when I’m baking, I just throw everything into my KitchenAid and start mixing. Turns out, that that’s a big no-no when it comes to baking. In Martha’s class, she notes the importance of the order of which you’re mixing your ingredients, because it can really impact the bake and texture of your cookies (two main issues I’ve been looking to fix)!

According to Martha (and proabably every other professional baker on this planet), you start by mixing the dry ingredients in a bowl that you then set aside for later (key). In your stand mixer bowl, you mix up the wet ingredients starting with butter and sugar. Then add in eggs and other flavorings like vanilla extract and orange, and only then, do you add in your dry ingredients.

And there I was, 21 minutes later with perfectly baked, decorated sugar cookies that looked like the cutest holiday wreathes. This recipe test was so successful I’m going to make these cookies in bulk to give as delicious stocking stuffers for the holidays! Want to give it a try to see for yourself? You can take Martha’s class here!

If you love taking class with Martha and want even more recipes from your favorite Food Network chefs, sign up for the Food Network Kitchen app here.

Related Links:

Next Up

Decorating with Fondant

Stuck with a cake decorating conundrum? Don't worry! We're here for you at Food Network Kitchens, with tips on everything you could ever want (or at least need) to know about using fondant to whip up your confectionary creations.

How I Keep My Smoke Detector From Going Off While Cooking — Safely!

You can sear a steak at home without the blare of a smoke detector going off in the background.

The Secret to Perfectly Cooked Steak Is Your Oven

Michael Symon shows off how to nail this not-so-scary recipe on the Food Network Kitchen app.

Suffer from Headaches? Tweaking Your Diet Might Help

What you eat may help relieve common tension headaches and even migraines.

There’s a Reason Baking Recipes Call for a Specific Size of Egg

Large vs. extra-large matters. But a little easy math can help you adjust on the fly.

How to Make the Most of Your Freezer Space

If you keep your freezer organized, you can store meat, produce, ice cream and leftovers all at the same time.

These Are the Foods You Just Can't Make In an Air Fryer

Some foods can't be cooked with hot air alone.

Is It OK to Reuse Plastic Sandwich or Freezer Bags?

Here's how often you can reuse zip-top bags, takeout containers and other food storage containers.

Meal Prep Strategies Food Network Staffers Swear By

Just one of these small changes can make a big difference in your weekly meal plan.