Don't Throw Out Your Leftover Halloween Candy

Bake with it instead!

Get a Complimentary 1-Year Subscription to the Food Network Kitchen App

Download Food Network Kitchen to sign up and get access to daily live classes, thousands of on-demand cooking classes, in-app grocery ordering and so much more. Own a Fire TV, Fire tablet or Echo Show? You can now get a 1-year complimentary subscription to the app — read here for more details. Terms and conditions apply.

While we love eating handful after handful of fun-sized chocolate bars, mini peanut butter cups and other classic Halloween candies as much as the next person, there comes a certain point where candy is the very last thing you want to see — or eat — on the days that follow Halloween night. Thankfully, the Food Network Kitchen app is here to help you transform all those chocolatey and nutty leftovers into something completely new with just a few spatula scraps and stand mixer whirls. From loaded chocolate chip cookies to candy-topped brownies, here are three delicious ways to use up all your lingering Halloween candy.

Absolutely anything goes with these candy-packed peanut butter and oatmeal monster cookies from master baker Dan Langan. Though Dan uses a delectable combination of chopped peanut butter cups, colorful chocolate-covered candies, rich toffee bits and mini chocolate chips in his version, he also notes you can make them with everything from milk or dark chocolate, to caramel popcorn to chocolate-covered peanuts or pretzels. “Really anything that’s going to have some great texture and fit with the whole chocolate-peanut butter flavor would be awesome in these cookies,” Dan says. Now all you really need to do is consult your candy bucket.

Christina Lane, Small Batch Brownies as seen on Food Network Kitchen

Photo by: Andrea Patton

Andrea Patton

If you’re concerned about all that sugar your kids (and you) consumed on Halloween night, cookbook author Christina Lane has the perfect way for all of you to still get your after dinner dessert fix without going too over-the-top with this small batch brownie recipe. Christina uses a 9x5 loaf pan to make her fudgy brownies, saying that doing so will give you “two large bakery-sized brownies or four smaller brownies.” This ensures that everyone gets the perfect-sized bite. Don’t forget to top your brownies with some M&Ms or other chocolate-covered candies before placing them in the oven to bake — not only will they have a little extra crunch as a result, it'll also further help dwindle down your candy pile.

You won’t want to miss this brand-new live class from chef Megan Mitchell premiering this Sunday, November 1st, at 8 p.m. EST. In it, Megan will walk you through how to take a few cups of her all-time favorite candy, Reese’s Pieces, and repurpose them to make a delicious batch of Dark Chocolate Reese’s Pieces Cookies. You’ll also use dark cocoa powder and brown sugar to give your batch an intense chocolatey flavor with just the right amount of chewy texture. Sounds like a true match made in heaven to us!

Related Links:

Next Up

All-Pink Starburst Packs Are Back — This Time with a Clothing Line

Never let anyone treat you like a yellow Starburst.

You Can Eat Candy for Breakfast with Sugarfina’s Latest Collection

Excuse us while we come down from our sugar high.

Bean Count: The Great Jelly Bean Debate

Black is the only flavor jelly bean sold by the whole bag. Do you leave the black jelly beans behind?

Walmart's Candy Bouquets Are the Ultimate Valentine's Day Gift

Now you don’t have to choose between flowers and chocolate.

10 Easy Homemade Candies That Make Great Last-Minute Gifts

When you've had your fill of cookies, move on to candy.

Candy Man: How to Make Alton Brown's Candy Corn

Alton Brown makes candy corn for Food Network Magazine, step-by-step.

Ever Wondered Where Your Halloween Candy Was Made?

Fill your candy bag with treats made close to home.