3 of a Kind: Baseball Steaks Step Up to the Plate

Photo by: David Nehmer ©2015 David Nehmer

David Nehmer, 2015 David Nehmer

3 of a Kind checks out three places across the country to try something cool, new and delicious.

As steakhouses regain popularity, cuts of meat beyond the New York strip and filet mignon are making their way onto menus. One of these cuts — the baseball steak — is made from the upper portion of a top sirloin. Once it’s cooked, you can clearly see what inspired this steak’s moniker, as the meat puffs up to resemble a baseball. This leaner cut has a rich flavor and is often less expensive than its counterparts, making it a home run for restaurants across the country.

Wollensky’s Grill, Chicago

Longtime steakhouse giant Smith and Wollensky decided to do something different at its outpost along the Chicago riverfront in 2014. The location was transformed to house this glass-fronted gastropub, which features various cuts of meat from an in-house butcher, as well as craft beer and shared plates. Sweeping views of the water add to the allure. On the lunch menu at Wollensky’s Grill you’ll find a decadent top-sirloin baseball steak, crusted with bone marrow and topped with cipollini onions.

Manny’s, Minneapolis

You can find just about any cut of steak at Manny’s, and all are dry-aged and hand-trimmed. The restaurant gives you the opportunity to get to know your cut up close before you even tuck into it, as the steaks are rolled out tableside via a meat trolley prior to diners placing their orders. Take advantage of this pre-meal ritual to learn about your cut of steak and how it will be prepared. The baseball steak, cut filet-style, is served a la carte and pairs perfectly with Manny’s heaping portions of steakhouse sides like hash browns and loaded mashed potatoes.

Pacific Dining Car, Los Angeles

This stalwart of the Los Angeles dining scene is known for its 24-hour service (with reduced late-night prices to boot) and dry-aged prime steaks that have been a specialty here since the 1920s. The baseball steak is one of Pacific Dining Car’s most-popular cuts. Juicy and flavorful, this thick cut is served plain or with a choice of toppings like French truffle butter or cracked peppercorns. The restaurant offers its baseball steak as a dinner option and also features a special 10-ounce late-night version made famous in the movie Training Day.

Photos courtesy of Wollensky’s Grill, Manny’s and Hagop Kalaidjian

Next Up

3 of a Kind: Scraps

Sending something to the scrapheap used to mean dooming it to its demise, but restaurants across the country are now making the most of scraps, turning carrot tops, bread butts, corn silks and more into incredible dishes that are worth saving and sav

3 of a Kind: Shakshouka

Shakshouka is a savory egg entree made with tomatoes, peppers and onions that's popular in Israel. Here are a few creative ways it's being adapted by chefs in America.

3 of a Kind: Baijiu

Find out which celebratory liquor is joining vodka, gin and the rest of the crew as a popular spirit.

3 of a Kind: Togarashi

Feeling the heat? Check out a chile-laced spice blend that is elevating everything from cheesecake to cocktails.

3 of a Kind: Cottage Cheese

Call it the ultimate cottage industry: Cottage cheese is making its way onto the menus of top restaurants around the country.

3 of a Kind: Miner’s Lettuce

A wild green with a fascinating past is showing up as an elegant garnish at restaurants around the country.

3 of a Kind: Veggie Burgers

Even carnivores are craving veggie patties, and chefs are answering the call with hearty two-handed burgers that are true meatless marvels.

3 of a Kind: Savory Pancakes

Pancakes aren’t just for breakfast anymore. These fresh takes on flapjacks flip the sweet standby into a savory dish, swapping in vegetables for fruit, with varied and extremely creative toppings.

3 of a Kind: Fermented Salads

Chefs are using pickled vegetables and fermented dressings to create tangy twists on typical salads.

3 of a Kind: Udon Shops

Udon — the chewier and plumper cousin to the ramen noodle — is slurping its way into the spotlight at these three shops.