The Next Iron Chef Bromance: Chefs That Plate Together, Win Together?

EPISODE2_INNOVATION

EPISODE2_INNOVATION

Rival Chef Amanda Freitag hugs fellow safe Rival Chef Elizabeth Falkner after the for the "White Bread" as seen on Food Network's Season 5.

Photo by: Eddy Chen/Creel Films ©2012, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Eddy Chen/Creel Films, 2012, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Something unprecedented happened on this past Sunday's episode of The Next Iron Chef. For the first time in Kitchen Stadium, two chefs chose to plate together, which led to their dishes being judged side by side. Was it a good or bad decision on their part? Did it tarnish the sanctity of the competition?

It's been evident from the beginning of Season 5 that Chefs Mendelsohn and Vigneron have had an alliance. Episode 4 showed viewers how deep their friendship goes. The two competed against one another in the secret ingredient elimination challenge and made the decision to plate their lobster dishes together. But were they to be judged together, sent home together or allowed to win together? All the rival chefs were up in arms by their actions. Ultimately the judges chose to send home Chef Mendelsohn.

FN Dish wants to know, what would you have done if you were a judge? Do you think what went down in Kitchen Stadium was fair? Would you have liked to have seen both chefs saved? Or would you have eliminated both chefs for their antics?

Keep Reading

Next Up

What to Watch: Iron Chef America With the Winner of The Next Iron Chef

Watch The Next Iron Chef winner, Alex Guarnaschelli, battle it out on Iron Chef America, against Iron Chef UK's Judy Joo.

Listen Carefully — The Next Iron Chef Caption It

Before you tune in Sunday at 9pm/8c to watch a new episode of Food Network's The Next Iron Chef, caption this sneak-peek photo of Alton Brown and Nate Appleman.

Cringe-Worthy — The Next Iron Chef Caption It

Caption this image of Simon Majumdar from Sunday's new episode of Food Network's Next Iron Chef: Redemption, and tune in Sunday at 9pm/8c to see what happened.

Raise the Bar — The Next Iron Chef Caption It

Before you tune in to the finale of Food Network's The Next Iron Chef on Sunday, December 23, at 9pm/8c, caption this photo of judge Donatella Arpaia.

Have You Visited the Next Iron Chef Online Headquarters?

Go to FoodNetwork.com/NIC to discover never-before-seen photos, video interviews and more of the chefs and judges featured on Food Network's The Next Iron Chef.

Captain Brown — The Next Iron Chef Caption It

Before you tune in Sunday at 9pm/8c to watch Food Network's The Next Iron Chef: Redemption, caption this photo of Alton Brown in a helicopter cockpit.

Play Time — The Next Iron Chef Caption It

Before you tune in to Food Network's Next Iron Chef on Sunday at 9pm/8c, caption this playful sneak-peek image of Chefs Nate Appleman and Eric Greenspan.

Chef Estes Makes the Final 10 — The Next Iron Chef Caption It

Before you tune in on Sunday, Nov. 4 at 9pm/8c to watch the premiere of Food Network's Next Iron Chef, caption this photo of the 10th rival chef, Duskie Estes.

A Look Back at The Next Iron Chef With Iron Chef Guarnaschelli, and Her Future in Kitchen Stadium

We recently sat down with Chef Guarnaschelli at Butter to chat about her experience on The Next Iron Chef: Redemption, why she decided to go for it a second-time and what her biggest fear about Kitchen Stadium is.