Thanksgiving Face-Off: Which is Healthier?

Food Network Magazine staged a Thanksgiving face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices. Here's how some staples compare.
By: Food Network Magazine


Thinkstock image of apple cider and cinnamon sticks

Photo by: Michael Gray

Michael Gray

Food Network Magazine staged a Thanksgiving face-off and asked a registered dietitian to name the better choices. Study up before the big meal: Here's how some staples compare.

Apple Cider vs. Sparkling Cider

WINNER: Apple cider. Sparkling cider is usually sparkling apple juice, which doesn't contain the same amount of fiber that unfiltered ciders do (the real stuff is a little cloudy). Plus, the spices that make cider so delicious, like cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, give you an antioxidant boost.

Chicken Leg

Chicken Leg

Thinkstock image of Barbecue Chicken Leg with white background

Dark Meat vs. White Meat

WINNER: It's a draw. White meat contains half the fat of drumsticks and thighs and fewer calories, but dark meat has more iron and twice as much zinc. And a new study suggests that the taurine in dark meat might help prevent heart disease.

Thinkstock image of pie shell

©2009 by Lynnette Peizer, All Rights Reserved

2009 by Lynnette Peizer, All Rights Reserved

Rolled Piecrust vs. Graham Cracker Piecrust

WINNER: Graham cracker piecrust. Recipes for rolled piecrusts typically call for a lot of butter and sometimes lard, so they are high in saturated fat. Graham cracker crusts are lower in fat and calories, and they contain some extra fiber.



Thinkstock image of Cranberry Sauce

Photo by: msheldrake


Whole Cranberry Sauce vs. Jellied Cranberry Sauce

WINNER: Whole cranberry sauce. Cranberries are loaded with antioxidants and fiber. But the main ingredient in jellied cranberry sauce is juice, which is packed with sugar and strained of nutrients. Jellied sauce also tends to be higher in calories by volume.



Thinkstock image of Rolls

Photo by: papik123


Biscuits vs. Dinner Rolls

WINNER: Dinner rolls. Multigrain or whole-wheat rolls are your best bet, but even white rolls are a smarter choice than biscuits. Biscuits can be packed with more than twice the fat and calories, and some contain a quarter of your daily sodium intake.

Our Expert: Takami Kim is a registered dietician with NewYork–Presbyterian Hospital's Department of Food and Nutrition Management

Keep Reading

Next Up

Quiz: Which Chopped Judge Are You?

Take the quiz to find out which Chopped judge you 're most compatible with.

Top 5 Recipes from Holiday Central

Check out the top-five recipes featured in's Holiday Central, the ultimate resource for all things seasonal cooking and entertaining.

POLL: What's the Centerpiece Dish on Your Holiday Table?

FN Dish wants to know: What main dish do you most often prepare for your holiday feast?

Thanksgiving Countdown Planner

Hosting Thanksgiving dinner and not sure where to start? Relax — getting ready for the holiday is easy with our tips and recipes.

Worry-Free Wine Presentation at Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving can bring out the worry. Happily, there's one area that doesn't require excessive concern, and that's wine presentation. Here are my stress-relieving tips:

Beyond Pie: Thanksgiving Cupcakes, Cakes and Cookies

Pies are the quintessential Thanksgiving dessert. But that doesn’t mean you can’t showcase fall flavors like pumpkin, pecan and apple in other sweets as well.

10 Thanksgiving Wine Tips And Pairings

Be the wine hero of Thanksgiving by bringing the perfect bottle — use our tips and wine pairing ideas.

5 Healthy Pie Recipes for Your Thanksgiving Table

When it comes to Thanksgiving, there's one kind of dessert that's bound to star in your spread: pie. And we mean lots of it.

5 Turkey-Themed Platters for Your Thanksgiving Feast

These festive, shareable platters are just the thing to tide over a hungry crowd before the turkey hits the table.

Beyond the Kids’ Table: How to Involve Kids in Thanksgiving Prep

When given enjoyable tasks, young children are naturally inclined to be helpful, so put them to work!