Nutrition News: BMI and Your Health

A recent study suggests that a higher BMI may actually lead to a longer life. So now being overweight is good for you? That’s not the whole story!
147460037

147460037

Young woman standing on a scale

Photo by: kzenon

kzenon

By now you’ve heard the long list of health risks associated with packing on extra pounds, but a recent study suggests that a higher BMI may actually lead to a longer life. So now being overweight is good for you? That’s not the whole story!

What is BMI?

Body Mass Index or BMI is a calculation that measures weight while adjusting for height. Here’s the formula for you math lovers:

Weight (kilograms) ÷ [Height (meters)]²

A BMI above 24.9 categorizes someone as overweight, while a BMI over 30 classifies someone as obese. When a less than stellar BMI is paired with other risk factors like smoking, physical inactivity or excessive waist circumference, your risk of chronic disease goes up. As BMI increases so does the risks diseases like heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

Making Sense of the Science

A 2013 report published in the Journal of the American Medical Association supported that obese people were still at greater risk for mortality, but those who were overweight actually had a lower mortality risk than those who were at a normal weight.

While one study never makes fact, this analysis did look at almost 100 studies and 3 million people and that gives it more weight (pun intended).

BMI is certainly not a perfect measurement and while it does look at weight and height, it doesn’t differentiate between fat and lean body mass. A lot of very fit athletes may have a BMI that classifies them as overweight or even obese because of the extra muscle they carry. Then again, most Americans are not fit athletes.

Bottom Line: The findings of this report do raise interesting questions about weight and overall health and there’s a need for more research. This report does provide more evidence that BMI alone isn’t the only way to evaluate health.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Nutrition News: Investigating Health Claims on Energy Drinks

Energy drinks are in the spotlight again: lawmakers in NY state are investigating the validity of their health claims. Our dietitian has investigated these claims as well.

Nutrition News: New Soda Health Claims, Benefits of Spicy Food and School Gardens

Diet Pepsi changes its formula, and Coke tries to change the conversation; spicy food may help you live longer; kids reap real benefits from school gardens.

Nutrition News: Fast Health, Fat-Fueled Sports and Another Reason to Drink Coffee

A study finds benefits in intermittent fasting; a high-fat diet may be good for athletes, but not everyone; and if you drink coffee, your arteries may be spick-and-span.

This Week's Nutrition News Feed

In this week's news: School bake-sale restrictions spark a tempest in a muffin tin; homemade yogurt is, yes, whey better than the store-bought kind; and veganism gets a high-profile new cheerleader.

The Week's Nutrition News Feed

In this week's news: more good news about oatmeal, fast-food receipts that make you rethink your order -- plus the latest glimpse into Americans' eating habits.

This Week's Nutrition News Feed

Tomato juice, ingredient labels, and tempeh in this week's Nutrition News.

This Week’s Nutrition News Feed

In this week’s news: reasons to eat more nuts, soda sales are on the decline, and how much more does healthful eating cost? (hint: not much!)

This Week's Nutrition News Feed

In this week's news: Vegetables save lives; baseball stadiums cater to the Whole Foods set; and scientists keep putting monkeys on wacky diets.

This Week's Nutrition News Feed

In this week's news: Rappers delight in healthy eating; Alice Waters predicts a farmers markets bonanza; and scientists do the important work of building a healthier hot dog.

This Week's Nutrition News Feed

In this week's news: Bean buffs have reason to rejoice; "plant-based protein" shapes up to be the other white meat; and vitamin D is back in the spotlight (make that the sunlight).