Update: Health Experts Weigh in on Proposed Nutrition Label Redo

Earlier this year, the FDA released details of the proposed nutrition label makeover. Many experts have been weighing in on the new look trying to determine if the proposed changes will help consumers make more informed decisions or add to the confusion.
nutrition facts label


Earlier this year, the Food and Drug Administration released details of the proposed nutrition label makeover. Many experts have been weighing in on the new look, trying to determine if the changes will help consumers make better-informed decisions or simply add to widespread confusion about nutrition. Last week, The New England Journal of Medicine published two commentaries from health experts.

Added Sugars, Packaging Buzzwords

The first perspective was written by David A. Kessler, MD, a professor at the University of California, San Francisco, author of The End of Overeating and a former FDA commissioner. Kessler believes that the FDA's proposed changes could help nudge food buyers toward healthier decisions but argues that the new label does not go far enough.

Given that many consumers tend to munch on high-calorie, high-sugar foods at the expense of more nutritious options, Kessler supports the proposed change to distinguish "added sugars" from "total sugars." In addition, he agrees that the serving size should reflect what a typical person would consume in one sitting -- another of the suggested revisions.

But Kessler proposes taking sugar labeling one step further by listing a percent daily value (DV) for added sugars that would help consumers quickly determine if what they're buying is high or low in such sweeteners.

In addition, the label's focus on individual nutrients, rather than whole foods, Kessler says, is a potential shortcoming: "There is nothing in the new framework that actively encourages consumers to purchase food rich in the fruits, vegetables and whole grains that are rightfully considered 'real food,'" Kessler writes. Such emphasis gives food manufacturers incentive to fortify processed foods that may have little nutritional worth -- such as sugary cereals -- with an endless list of vitamins and minerals, in an effort to catch consumers' eyes, and to make healthful-sounding claims along the lines of "high-fiber" or "low-fat."

Other experts also express concern about ingredient lists and possibly misleading label buzzwords. Allison C. Sylvetsky, PhD, and William H. Dietz, MD, PhD, both at George Washington University's Milken Institute School of Public Health, co-authored a second perspective paper for the journal. They point out that many chemical names for ingredients, including artificial sweeteners such as aspartame and sucralose, aren't recognizable to consumers. Many foods containing artificial sweeteners promote themselves as being "low in sugar" or having "no added sugar." Such claims may give parents a false sense of security about certain foods and lure them into choosing highly processed items for children. Artificially sweetened products, the authors also note, may be sweeter than their sugar-spiked counterparts and can still cultivate a sweet tooth in children.

Sylvetsky and Dietz recommend that the FDA adopt a more straightforward and easily understandable ingredient labeling system similar to what's in place in Canada, where packaged foods indicate if they contain one or more artificial sweetener. More transparent food marketing, they say, will help empower parents to make better educated food choices for children.

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. She is the author of The Greek Yogurt Kitchen: More Than 130 Delicious, Healthy Recipes for Every Meal of the Day.

Next Up

The Nutrition Label's New Look

The food label on packaged food has been there since the early 1990’s. With all the label confusion, the FDA finally decided it was time the nutrition label got a makeover (we couldn’t agree more!). Although the proposed changes were released a few months ago, a new black and white food label photo was released this morning.

Picnic Foods Nutrition Experts Avoid

We asked expert dietitians from around the country which barbecue and picnic foods they tell their clients to avoid.

Nutrition News: BMI and Your Health

A recent study suggests that a higher BMI may actually lead to a longer life. So now being overweight is good for you? That’s not the whole story!

5 Shortcut Foods Nutrition Experts Love

Not every store-bought item that makes it easier to pull together a meal is overly processed. Here are shortcut foods nutrition experts rely on when they're in a hurry.

Nutrition News: Nutrition Labels, GMO-Free Products and Organic Recalls

Front-of-pack nutrition labels prompt buying, more GMO-free products contain labels, and organic-product recalls have increased.

Nutrition News: Chipotle Unseats Subway, FDA Added-Sugar Label Rules and Soybean Oil Health Effects

Subway cedes top “healthy” chain spot to Chipotle; FDA to require added-sugar info on labels; and a study says soybean oil may be making us fat and diabetic.

Food Labeling 101: Understanding the Nutrition Facts Label

Don't be afraid of the food label on prepared foods; learn to read it right and it can be your best tool to aid with healthy eating.

Nutrition News: Investigating Health Claims on Energy Drinks

Energy drinks are in the spotlight again: lawmakers in NY state are investigating the validity of their health claims. Our dietitian has investigated these claims as well.

5 Foods Nutrition Experts Think Deserve More Love

Here, nutrition experts weigh in on the top five foods you may not be eating -- but should be.

How to Read Everything on the Nutrition Facts Label

This dietitian’s practical advice for deciphering nutrition labels.