Time to Embrace a Low-Carb Diet? (Or Not So Fast?)

Was Atkins on the right track in the 1970’s when he said we should give up all carbs? A new study, however, found that eating a low-carb diet lost more body weight and reduced their risk for heart disease. So should you be saying goodbye to all your carbs? Unfortunately, it’s not that simple.
chocolate muffins


freshly made chocolate muffins

A study out earlier this week has been generating lots of buzz with its finding that study participants on a low-carb diet lost more body weight and reduced their risk of heart disease compared to subjects on a low-fat diet. So should we be saying goodbye to all carbs?

The study, published in the Annals of Internal Medicine and sponsored by the National Institutes of Health, was a randomized trial that followed a group of 150 racially diverse men and women over one year. The subjects were divided into two groups: One group limited the amount of fat, while the second group limited the amount of carbs they ate. Neither group was asked to scale back on total calories or to alter physical activity.

After one year, researchers found that those in the low-carb group lost an average of 8 pounds more compared with those in the low-fat group. In addition, the low-carb group lost significantly more body fat compared with those in the low-fat group.

Wait, There’s More

It's tempting to want to shout from rooftops, "low carb-diets rule!," but that may not necessarily the case. The low-carb group was eating higher fat, but mainly from unsaturated sources such as nuts, fish and olive oil. Butter was sometimes eaten, but wasn't a primary ingredient in their overall diets. Their total fat intake was more than 40 percent of their total calories.

The low-fat group included all types of carbs, such as those from whole grains, refined breads, cereals and other starches. Their total fat intake was about 30 percent of their total calorie intake, which is in line with the USDA's Dietary Guidelines for Americans.

This study suggests there's more going on here than meets the eye. Although the low-carb group did reduce their risk for heart disease on one type of assessment test, the size of their "bad" LDL cholesterol was never measured, something that would have given researchers a better picture of their heart health (small, dense LDL particles are associated with atherosclerosis and other conditions). Additionally, the types of carbs a person eats matters. The USDA's guidelines emphasize "making half your grains whole," due to whole grains' overwhelming benefits. This study did not differentiate between refined carbs and those from whole grains.

The Bottom Line: This study doesn't differentiate between types of fat (unsaturated versus saturated) and type of carbs (refined versus whole grains), making it difficult to draw certain conclusions, especially when it comes to heart health. The best bet is to include both whole grains and healthy unsaturated fat as part of a wholesome, well-balanced diet while minimizing refined and processed foods.

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. She is the author of The Greek Yogurt Kitchen: More Than 130 Delicious, Healthy Recipes for Every Meal of the Day.

Next Up

The Best Low-Carb Foods

Not all carbs are created equal.

Going Low Carb: Good or Bad?

Many dieters revert back to the "low-carb” Atkins or South Beach plans to lose weight. Certain carbohydrate-rich foods are vital to your good health. Find out if you’re eating the right kinds.

Easy High-Protein, Low-Carb Meals

Satiate your appetite longer with these dietitian-approved ideas.

10 Low-Carb Hacks You Need to Try

Including three different ways to make pizza crust!

Is a Low-Carb Diet Good for High Cholesterol?

Get the lowdown on how low-carb diets affect cholesterol levels, and find out more ways to lower LDL and boost HDL.

How I “Tricked” My Parents Into Eating Low-Carb Pasta

Because picky eating isn’t just a kid-thing.

What Is Low-Carb Pasta — and Which One Is Right for You?

With so many to choose from, the alternative pasta aisle can be overwhelming. Here's a breakdown of four versatile low-carb pastas to try.

Related Pages