Should You Be Drinking Milk? (And If So, What Kind?)

There’s a debate raging around dairy, with some people advocating its consumption for a variety of health reasons, and others shunning it based on their own digestive or ethical concerns. But the new dietary guidelines are clear. They continue to recommend three servings per day of dairy as the best way to meet the requirements for calcium, potassium, vitamin D, vitamin A and magnesium. “The guidelines say that dairy is crucial, because for most Americans it is the primary source of those nutrients that many come up short on,” says Isabel Maples, RDN, spokesperson for the Academy for Nutrition and Dietetics.

But many Americans experience symptoms of lactose intolerance that make consuming dairy products particularly unpleasant. The gas, bloating and diarrhea are caused by an inability to digest lactose — the sugar that naturally occurs in cow’s, sheep’s and goat’s milk.

Recently, however, science has started to tease out another possible explanation for many people’s post-dairy discomfort. “Researchers looked into why people who thought they were lactose-intolerant could drink goat’s milk without issue, even though it has as much lactose as cow’s milk,” says Bonnie Johnson, M.S., R.D., nutrition director, a2 Milk Company.

It turns out that it’s not just the lactose that’s a problem. Many more people are actually reacting to milk’s A1 protein — a genetic mutation that occurred in cows as dairy farming became bigger and herds were bred for increased milk production.

Goats and sheep don’t have this mutation, so their milk contains only the easier-to-digest A2 protein. A new product, simply called a2 Milk, is sourced from small herds of cows that have all been DNA tested to confirm that their milk contains only the A2 protein.

For those who truly are lactose-intolerant, however, the solution remains avoiding large quantities of dairy, especially milk. “Many people can still tolerate yogurt and aged cheese, because they actually contain very little lactose,” says Maples.

Check the nutrition facts label for the amount of carbohydrate in a dairy product — if it contains little to none, that means there’s little to no lactose. And the dietary guidelines do rank fortified soy milk on par with dairy (but not other nondairy alternatives such as rice and nut milks), because its nutrition profile most closely matches that of cow’s milk.

Sally Wadyka is a Boulder, Colorado-based journalist who writes about nutrition, health and wellness.

Next Up

Why You Should Drink Port

In world of Unicorn Frappuccinos, port is like grandpa yelling at the grandkids to put their phones down and have some darn respect.

What's So Bad About Trans Fats?

These dangerous fats lurk in lots of packaged foods. Find out what they are and how to avoid them.

Drink Pink: How Rosé Got So Popular

If you’ve found yourself suddenly drinking rosé wine, you’re part of a national trend. But how did the pretty pink wine get so popular, so suddenly?

What to Drink with Bobby's Menu

Round out Bobby Flay's Thanksgiving menu with Food Network's wine pairing guide to see what to drink with his spicy, feisty meal.

QUIZ: What Thanksgiving Stuffing Should You Make?

Find out what stuffing you should serve with your feast.

One Small Change: What Makes Superfoods So Super?

Superfoods have been all the rage for years, but what makes them so super? Should you spend extra money on exotic ones, or can you find them in your grocery store?

Should You Drink Bottled Water or Tap Water?

Should you be dropping cash on bottled water or is tap the way to go? We’re diving into this controversy and sprinkling you with all the facts.

What Is Yakult and Why Is It So Popular?

This one goes out to all the boys we've loved before.