Healthy Debate: Which Diet Is Best?

diet concept


Diet concept

Photo by: george tsartsianidis

george tsartsianidis

Over the past two decades, diet crazes have flip-flopped from low calorie to low fat to low carb to high protein. Somewhere along the way, the high-fat “Mediterranean” style also gained popularity. So which of these conflicting concepts is the best for weight loss? There hasn’t been solid research to investigate the long-term results – until now. A recent study charted the progress of more than 800 subjects on 4 types of diets for two years.  We're breaking down the results.

The Dilemmas

Trying to lose weight is hard enough, but when the advice always seems to be changing, it’s enough for many folks to throw in the weight loss towel. Some of the main issues that send dieters reeling are:

  • Conflicting information – one day it’s low carb, the next day it’s high fat...
  • Nutrition advice comes from unreliable sources
  • Some diets are incredibly hard to stick to
  • Some diets only allow for short term weight loss -- what’s the point of losing weight if you can keep it off, right?!
So is there a difference among these various types?
The Research

There aren’t many reliable studies out there on the various types of diets. Many of the studies that have been done haven’t tracked progress for more than one year, which makes the long term effects hard to assess.

Some smaller studies have found that low carb “Atkins” type diets may yield a slightly faster initial weight loss over some of the other plans. But by the 12-month mark, the total amount of weight lost seems to be the same no matter which type of diet you follow. Dieters who’ve followed the low-carb style plans tend to complain of numerous adverse effects including fatigue and constipation (that doesn’t seem worth it to me).

Now, longer-term research is finally available. A study published in the New England Journal of Medicine followed 811 overweight men and women ages 30 to 70 were placed on reduced-calorie diets in 4 categories:

  • Low-fat, average protein
  • Low fat, high protein
  • High-fat, average protein
  • High-fat, high-protein (low carb)

In addition to their diet plans, the participants received nutrition education and instruction for 2 years.

After six months, all dieters averaged a loss of about 13 pounds and began to regain some of the weight after 12 months. At the end of 2 years, 80-percent of the participants completed the trial and the average weight loss was about 8 pounds per person. Attendance to the educational sessions was strongly associated with weight loss.

Bottom Line: It has been substantiated by research that a reduced calorie diet with continuing nutrition education is the way to go. Instead of worrying so much about low carb or high fat, try for a well-balanced diet with an appropriate calorie reduction for long term success.

TELL US: What's your take on the latest dieting trends?

Dana Angelo White, MS, RD, ATC, is a registered dietitian, certified athletic trainer and owner of Dana White Nutrition, Inc., which specializes in culinary and sports nutrition. See Dana's full bio »

You Might Also Like:

Next Up

Healthy Debate: Are Detox Diets Safe?

Sure, it's tempting to try a detox or cleanse diet after all that Thanksgiving turkey, but are they safe? Here's what experts at the American Dietetic Association's recent Food and Nutrition Expo had to say about these controversial diets.

Which Fad Diets Are Celebrities On?

Here’s a look at four fad diets; you won’t believe who’s on them!

Healthy Debate: Is Your Juice Safe?

Recently, a California environmental group found that juice drinks and packaged fruit contained lead above the allowable level. Find out what this advocacy group discovered and what the FDA is telling consumers. We’ll let you decide.

Healthy Debate: Chocolate Verses White Milk

Sweet chocolate milk is causing bitter cafeteria showdowns around the country. School lunch advocates who want the chocolate stuff nixed from the cafeteria menu say it packs almost as much sugar as soda, but others say it's better for kids to drink chocolate milk than no milk at all.

Healthy Debate: Frozen vs. Fresh Veggies

And the winner is…farm fresh veggies! But don’t count out the frozen ones -- there’s a time and place for them too. Find out the advantages of using frozen veggies and what you should be looking for when buying them at the market.

Healthy Debate: Should You Choose Organic?

Is it worth the extra cost to buy organic or does healthy conventionally grown food trump pesticide free?

Healthy Diet Excuses and Solutions

We asked top nutrition experts from around the country some of the most popular weight loss excuses they’ve heard over the years. Do any of them sound familiar?

Healthy Debate: Should You Avoid Food Dyes?

The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) is calling for a ban on several of the most common food dyes, saying they lead to hyperactivity in children. Last week, however, the FDA claimed the evidence wasn’t strong enough to warrant a ban. Here's the latest on this hot debate.

Healthy Debate: Should Happy Meal Toys Be Banned?

Whoever came up with the marketing for Happy Meals toys is a genius. Kids are drawn to popular characters and love their trinkets ( more than the food). But with this type of marketing comes a price—especially when you’re talking about high fat and calorie-laden food during a time where tremendous efforts are being put forth to diminish the incidence of childhood obesity.