Ask the Dietitian: Should You Keep Your Weight Loss Plans a Secret?

One of the most popular New Year’s resolutions is to lose weight. But once you begin your diet plan, should you announce it to everyone or keep quiet?
diet secret

One of the most popular New Year’s resolutions is to lose weight. But once you begin your diet plan, should you announce it to everyone or keep your lips sealed?

Q: What's the best way to ensure weight loss success, tell your friends and loved ones or keep it secret?

A: There’s no right or wrong way to do it. At the end of the day, to get rid of that gut, you’ve got to go with your gut!

Research supports that a lack of motivation and accountability are common barriers to dropping those pounds. That’s why weight loss programs like Weight Watchers consider meetings and weigh-ins keys to success. On the other hand, some experts argue that you’re better off keeping things quiet.

Oftentimes the mentality that you’re ON or OFF a diet can trip you up. Announcing this to others may make them (consciously or unconsciously) attempt to stifle your progress.  Sometimes, just being around those that aren’t following a healthy eating plan can be enough to derail you. Those who decide to keep their plans hush-hush believe that announcing weight loss intentions ahead of time can lead to self-sabotage. They also argue that there’s an additional benefit of showing off your weight loss after the fact.

The only way to successfully lose weight is to make changes and stick to them. For the best results, you’ve got to decide what tactics will work best for you.

If weight loss is on your 2012 to-do list, here are some tips for success:

  • Get nutrition advice from qualified nutrition professionals – registered dietitians have been properly trained in weight loss and nutrition counseling.
  • Find something that motivates you. Whether it’s a buddy at the gym or treating yourself to a non-food reward (manicure, anyone?).
  • Make a contract with yourself.
  • Check the research on Which Diet is Best?
  • Try our 10 Non-Resolution Resolutions.
Tell Us: For weight loss, what’s your preference? Share or keep things under wraps?

You Might Also Like:

Dana Angelo White, MS, RD, ATC, is a registered dietitian, certified athletic trainer and owner of Dana White Nutrition, Inc., which specializes in culinary and sports nutrition. See Dana's full bio »

Next Up

Should You Take Diabetes Drug Ozempic for Weight Loss?

Improper use of the drug has led to a shortage.

Unexpectedly Helpful Foods for Weight Loss

Focusing on these foods may help you peel off the pounds more quickly.

Here Are the Best Fats for Weight Loss

Good-for-you fats exist, and you need to start eating them.

Do Diet Drinks Actually Help With Weight Loss?

A new study shows that no- or low-calorie sweetened drinks can be just as, if not more, effective as swapping in water in place of sweetened drinks.

A Dietitian’s Review of Sakara’s Insta-Famous Meal Plans

I was super skeptical about Sakara’s marketing on social media, but there was actually a lot to like about the meals themselves.

Why You Shouldn’t Take Berberine Supplements for Weight Loss

An expert explains why you should think twice before taking what is being called "nature’s Ozempic" on social media.

7 Foods to Include in a Weight Loss Diet

Don't waste your money on secret potions and potentially dangerous supplements to lose weight. Including these real foods in your diet is a safer way to lose weight.

Everything You Want to Know About Alcohol and Weight Loss

If I quit drinking will I lose weight? This dietitian is six months sober and digging into the research.

What Parents Need to Know About the AAP’s New Weight Loss Guidelines for Kids

We asked registered dieticians to break down the American Academy of Pediatrics’ recently released guidelines, which are the first of their kind in 15 years.

Which Foods Should You Keep or Toss Out After a Cookout?

After a gathering outside, consider time and temperature when figuring out what’s safe to have as leftovers.