Diet Myths, Debunked: Does Eating Late Cause Weight Gain?

How many times have you heard that you shouldn’t eat after 8 pm? Does the time you eat really play a role in weight gain? Yes and no—we’ll explain.
Related To:

How many times have you heard that you shouldn’t eat after 8 pm? Does the time you eat really play a role in weight gain? Yes and no — we’ll explain.

It’s All About Balance

It’s really what you eat and how much you eat throughout the day that makes a difference. If someone eats well-balanced meals throughout the day and starts snacking on loads of food at night (healthy or junkie), that will lead to weight gain. I remember late night study parties in college -- ordering up pizzas and wings every night will definitely lead to the freshman 15.  But simply eating late at night won't tip the scale.

Spreading Out Your Meals

It’s not about how late you eat, but the actual timing of meals. What's a normal meal pattern?  Well, you should eat three meals and two to three healthy snacks a day. There should be no more than five hours between meals to keep blood sugar and energy levels under control. So a person who eats breakfast at 10 a.m., lunch a 3 p.m. and dinner at  8 p.m. won’t necessarily gain weight because they’re eating dinner at 8 p.m. However, if you wait too long between meals or skip meals — say breakfast was at 10 a.m. and the next meal was at 8 p.m. -- studies show that this can lead to binging at the next meal.

The Role of Snacks

What you choose to eat at each snack is equally important. Each snack should contain between 150-200 calories. Here are a few healthy snack options:

  • Apple with peanut butter
  • Crackers and cheese
  • Cut up veggies dipped in low fat dressing
  • A handful of nuts

Many folks start devouring everything in sight after dark— that’s when it gets ugly. Even healthy snacks can turn into hundreds of late-night calories, especially in front of the TV. I see this trend a lot in my clients,  and it’s a tough behavior to control.  Different solutions work for different people -- some curb snacking by not eating after a certain hour, while others control portion sizes by paying attention to portion sizes.  Turning off the TV and eating at the table may work for you. Check out our post on late-night snacks for more tips.

The Bottom Line: It’s not about the time of day you eat, but rather energizing your body with sensible meals and snacks throughout the day. Mindless late-night snacking is what gets many people into trouble. Controlled portions of healthier options is your best bet.

TELL US: Are you a late-night snacker?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

You Might Also Like:

Keep Reading

Next Up

50 Late-Night Snacks

Find a new way to satisfy your midnight cravings.

Healthy Diet Excuses and Solutions

We asked top nutrition experts from around the country some of the most popular weight loss excuses they’ve heard over the years. Do any of them sound familiar?

Fruit Leather Roll-Ups — Food Network Kitchens

Behind-the-scenes info on the fruit leather roll-ups in the September issue of Food Network Magazine.

Smarter Snacks: Picks for During & After School

When I tell my younger clients to eat 3 meals and 2 to 3 small, healthy snacks a day, they often look at me with a puzzled face and say, “I’m supposed to snack?” Well, yes, of course, but it's all about picking wisely. Kids should get 25% of their daily calories from snacks, so these mini-meals should be full of vitamins and minerals to help them grow. But the question is: what’s a healthy snack that your kid will want to eat?

Healthy Snacks for a Day at the Beach

Heading out for a day of sun, sand and surf? Fill your beach bag with the right snacks so you're not tempted to answer the call of the ice cream man.

Healthy Snacking at Work

You'll be able to resist the snack machine if you stock your office with healthier snacks like popcorn, frozen grapes and nuts.

Food Network Stars Share Their Go-To Midnight Snacks

Hear from your favorite Food Network chefs to see what foods they crave in the middle of the night.

5 Ways to Cut 100 Calories: Snacks

Snacking on healthy foods can help maintain a healthy weight and keep energy levels high throughout the day. The only downside -- you can overdo healthy foods too! We’re taking a look at 5 healthy options and shaving off 100 calories from each.

Smarter Snacks: At the Vending Machine

It’s afternoon, you forgot to pack a snack and that candy bar in the vending machine is sweetly calling your name. Whether you're at work or stuck after school, sometimes the vending machine is the only option. Tell the candy bar to shut up and type in the numbers for these smarter alternatives.