Food Fight: Regular Soda vs. Diet Soda

Should you go for the sugar-filled soda or the one made with artificial stuff? Find out which is better to sip on when you're in the mood for soda.
soda

153978299

Brown soda in a clear glass

Photo by: Brent Hofacker

Brent Hofacker

Should you go for the sugar-filled soda or the one made with artificial stuff? Find out which is better to sip on when you're in the mood for soda.

Regular Soda

It's filled with sugar and a ton of empty calories, but soda can be part of a healthy eating plan if it's consumed rarely and as a special treat. However, studies have found that soda is one of the top sources of sugar in our diets. New York City has even tried to ban the sale of sugary beverages that are larger than 16 fluid ounces to help keep soda portions in check.

In addition to leading to weight gain, studies have found that folks who guzzle large amounts of soda tend to drink less milk and take in fewer nutrients like calcium. Furthermore, drinking large amounts of soda can be detrimental to your bones. Soda contains high amounts of phosphates, which can deplete the body's calcium stores.

Diet Soda

Although you may save on calories, diet soda has a whole other set of issues. First, the drink provides zero nutritional value. Food you choose to ingest should add good-for-you vitamins, minerals or phytonutrients. Second, the phosphates found in diet or regular soda can deplete calcium stores (as mentioned above).

Lastly and most controversial are the artificial sweeteners diet soda possesses. Although artificial sweeteners are on the government's Generally Recognized As Safe List (GRAS) there has been much debate as to whether consuming them regularly is good for you. Given that artificial sweeteners can now be found in a wide variety of foods (like yogurt, ice cream, cookies, salad dressings and iced teas other beverages) you may be taking in more than you think.

Some diet sodas also use Stevia, but that's also processed and controversy looms about its long-term safety.

Healthy Eats Winner: Although both beverages have a long list of cons, diet soda wins this fight by the smallest of margins. Drinking large amounts of regular soda has been shown to lead to weight gain and a variety of long health conditions and switching to diet can help cut calories and shed pounds. However, whether you decide to drink diet or regular soda, neither should be consumed in large amounts. The healthiest beverage out there is still or sparkling water, so making water your beverage of choice is the best option.

TELL US: Who gets your vote: regular or diet soda?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

Next Up

Star in Training

The Next Food Network Star winner Aarti Sequeira takes us through the making of her new show, Aarti Party.

Club Soda vs. Seltzer: What’s the Difference?

The differences between all the types of bubbly water.

Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder: What's the Difference?

Surprise, the model volcano in grade school explains a lot.

What Is Baking Soda?

A question you might wonder as you bake those cookies.

What Is Irish Soda Bread?

And why does it have a cross in the center?

McDonald’s Plans to Ditch Self-Serve Sodas

In the future, pouring your own refills will be a thing of the past.

Diet 101: Ayurvedic Diet

Ayurvedic eating is pretty much the opposite of a fad diet — it’s existed for some 5,000 years. Here’s what you need to know about doshas, kitchari bowls and eating mindfully.

Is Instant Coffee Healthier Than Regular Coffee?

Choosing instant may be better for you and the environment depending on your coffee habits.