How to Pick a Healthy Frozen Treat

Related To:
163655006

163655006

Frozen yogurt on spoon

Photo by: vikif

vikif

Nobody loves a good frozen treat more than I do, which is why it bugs me when I see store shelves overflowing with "diet" offerings that fool folks into thinking they're better than good old ice cream. The next time you've got a hankering for a frozen treat, here are some useful tips.

Low-Fat Ice Cream

Light and low-fat ice creams make up for the removal of fat by adding thickeners like guar gum, locust bean gum and carrageenan (just to name a few). Since fat also provides flavor, some lightened varieties include more sugar to make up for it, which means the calories can wind up being similar to regular ice cream. More sugar, less fat, same calories – not exactly healthier. And don't be fooled by the term slow churned; some brands may be using new technology to alter the consistency, while others may simply have more thickeners added in.

Frozen Yogurt

Reaching for frozen yogurt as a healthier alternative to ice cream? You'll be gaining the benefit of tummy-pleasing probiotics, but be aware that some fro-yos have two times more sugar than ice cream. There are many good options available with moderate amounts of sugar and fat, just don't automatically assume that every variety of yogurt will be lower in calories than ice cream.

Sugar-Free Ice Cream

Ice creams labeled "no sugar added" will still have a small amount of naturally existing sugars from milk. Since ice cream without sweetness just wouldn't be a treat, these options rely on artificial sweeteners (and a lot of them!). Folks who suffer from conditions such as diabetes may find no-sugar-added options useful but should keep in mind they can't eat the entire container.

Italian Ice

There's no fat to be found in this frozen goodie but the sugar is through the roof, making the calories comparable to some kinds of ice cream. There's no worry about cholesterol either, but an average 6-ounce cup has about 5 teaspoons of sugar, plus thickeners and artificial colors.

Bottom Line: Ingredient list reading is a MUST. Make sure you know what's in your low-fat or low-cal frozen treat of choice. And consider whether you might be better off with a small portion of the real thing!

Tell Us: What's your top choice for a healthy frozen treat?

Dana Angelo White, MS, RD, ATC, is a registered dietitian, certified athletic trainer and owner of Dana White Nutrition, Inc., which specializes in culinary and sports nutrition. See Dana's full bio »

Keep Reading

Next Up

Breakdown: Frozen Treats

What's the difference between ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, sherbet, gelato and frozen kefir?

Beat the Heat With Frozen Treats

Stay cool and refreshed with these frozen summertime sweet recipes including ice cream, ice pops and granitas.

Here’s the Scoop on Homemade Frozen Treats: DIY Ice Cream, Sorbet and Sherbet

Give homemade frozen treats a try with these recipes for ice cream, sorbet and sherbet. Stars like Ree Drummond give you recipes that come out fruity, extra-chocolatey and absolutely delicious.

Healthy Swaps: Ice Cream Toppings

Ice cream lovers tend to forget that toppings can pile up the calorie and fat. Consider our tips before making your next sundae.


Chefs’ Picks: Secret Indulgences

Even chefs have special comfort foods that are kind of unhealthy and possibly somewhat embarrassing for them to admit they eat. Find out which secret indulgences some chefs can’t resist.

5 Frozen Treats for a Sweet Fourth — Summer Soiree

Celebrate America's birthday with these sweet frozen desserts, guilt-free.

A Healthy Summer Treat: Banana "Ice Cream"

Monique Volz, from Ambitious Kitchen, joins us each Friday in May to recap her week in our Healthy Every Week Challenge.

Healthy or Not: Halo Top Ice Cream

Does Halo Top ice cream deserve its angel status? Our resident dietitian weighs in.

Dessert of the Month: Frozen Blueberry and Banana Ice Cream

Keep your freezer stocked with frozen fruit this summer for a sweet treat you can make with just four ingredients.