5 “Health” Foods That Are Overrated

energy bar


Muesli Bars isolated on white background

Photo by: Alex Skopje

Alex Skopje

There are plenty of things that are -- without debate -- good for you. A plate of steamed vegetables with brown rice, for example. Or a bowl of fresh fruit. Or a piece of poached salmon. But there's a long list of other foods that, despite wearing a so-called "health halo," might not be the nutritional powerhouses everyone seems to think they are.

Energy bars: At some point over the past few years, energy bars and protein bars transitioned from something endurance athletes ate while (literally) on the run, into quick snacks or meal replacements for ordinary people. But many are high in calories and saturated fat, low in fiber and loaded with high-fructose corn syrup or other sweeteners -- and are essentially no healthier than candy bars. "Look for bars with at least 3 grams of fiber, at least 5 five grams of protein and less than 2 grams of saturated fat," says Pam Fullenweider, RDN, a dietitian based in Houston.

Frozen yogurt: Low-fat or nonfat yogurt that's not sweetened and that contains live cultures (not all do) can be a not-so-guilty pleasure. But load it with sugar and turn it into a frozen confection, and most, if not all, of any health benefits are lost. And for anyone heaping things like crushed cookies or candies on top, don't kid yourself that your snack is any healthier -- or even much lower in calories -- than ice cream.

Gluten-free foods: Slap the words "gluten-free" on a label and suddenly people think it's better for them and will even help them lose weight. "But unless someone has celiac disease or a diagnosed gluten sensitivity, going for gluten-free is unnecessary," says Leslie Bonci, RD, director of sports nutrition at the UPMC Center for Sports Medicine, in Pittsburgh. Many such foods "are lacking in whole grains and fiber -- plus they come at a higher price tag," Bonci says.

Red wine: Studies have shown that people who drink one to two glasses of wine a day have a lower risk of heart disease, but there's equally robust research finding that women who drink even one glass a day have a higher risk of breast cancer. "A little is fine, but just don't think that red wine is actually a nutritious food like fruits and veggies," says Martica Heaner, PhD, adjunct assistant professor of nutrition at Hunter College, in New York City.

Over-the-Top Salads: No one would deny that a big bowl full of greens and other vegetables is a smart pick. But in order for a salad to earn its place at the healthy table, the eater needs to cast a critical eye on what else is included. "Toppings like candied nuts, dried fruit, cheese and croutons -- plus a creamy dressing -- can make a salad very high in calories and fat," Fullenweider says. Don't be surprised to find out that your super-size salad tops out at 1,000 calories or more.

Sally Wadyka is a Boulder, Colorado-based journalist who writes about nutrition, health and wellness.

Next Up

Reading List: Top 5 Overrated Food Trends, McDonald's Food Safety & A Dating Site Scandal

In this week’s nutrition news: Healthy People’s Newest Goals, dating site kicks off overweight members, and how small changes can keep diabetes at bay

Health Benefits of Thanksgiving Foods

Here’s a little something to make you feel better about all the eating that comes along with the Thanksgiving meal! A whole bunch of those holiday staples have serious health benefits.

5 Surprising Health Benefits of Avocados

These super fruits are not only delicious, but are also packed with nutritional and health benefits that may surprise you.

7 Health Food Trends for 2014

Which ingredients will be in health food stores everywhere? And what will restaurant menus be peddling? Here's the scoop for 2014.

Food Labeling: Beware the “Health” Halo

Many folks read food labels to gain better insight on the foods they choose. However, with so many claims plastered on labels things can get really confusing. Even worse, food companies use these claims to push certain products and make you think they’re healthier than they really are. Curious about the top 10 food label boobie traps?

Health-Food Store Bulk Bins: Worth It?

You can find practically everything in bulk bins these days. Here's why buying these products makes sense:

5 Overly-Processed Foods

If you're looking to clean up your diet, start by eliminating processed foods such as packaged pastries and fake whipped cream.

5 Flu-Fighting Foods

Eat more of these foods to help protect your health during flu season.

5 Foods for Romance

Whether you believe in the power of aphrodisiac foods or not, some can be quite healthy or at least worth a try.