Vegan Foods That Aren't as Nutritious as They Seem

Photo by: Stephen Johnson ©2014, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved.

Stephen Johnson, 2014, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved.

Food marketers know that certain nutrition “buzzwords,” such as natural, organic, gluten-free and vegan, are perceived by consumers to be healthier. Don’t fall for that trap, often referred to as the “halo effect.” Just because a food is vegan doesn’t mean it’s necessarily healthier for you than its counterpart that contains dairy, egg or meat. Here are five potential offenders.

homemade chocolate cake on a baking sheet


homemade chocolate cake on a baking sheet

Photo by: repinanatoly ©repinanatoly

repinanatoly, repinanatoly

Baked Goods

Most vegan baked goods are just as bad as, if not worse than, their dairy-and-egg equivalents. Often lots of sugars (e.g., corn syrup, agave, honey) and oils high in saturated fat are added to achieve the flavors and textures needed to allow for vegan desserts to compete with other decadent options. However, nutritious options do exist — look for the use of whole grains, vegetables, fruits and nuts in the recipe or as the first ingredients in the ingredient list.

Scoop of chocolate ice cream


Scoop of chocolate ice cream

Photo by: Jamie Grill

Jamie Grill

Ice Cream

Re-creating ice cream without milk used to be a tall order. These days almost anything can be whipped and frozen, from soy to coconut. But don’t let the lack of dairy fool you — some of these frozen confections can have more calories and fat than most standard ice cream brands. Just like regular ice cream, this is a treat and should be enjoyed in moderation. And if you’d rather go with sorbet, choose ones with minimal added sugar … fruit is sweet enough as it is!

Coconut Milk in a glass on dark wooden background (close-up shot)

Coconut Milk

Coconut Milk in a glass on dark wooden background (close-up shot)


There is a wide range of non-dairy options, including soy, hemp, coconut, rice and almond milks. While the use of these milks is not bad per se, it’s important to be aware of two key points when choosing your milk: sugar and nutrient content. Go for the unsweetened version of your preferred milk, as food manufacturers can easily add 3 to 4 teaspoons of sugar per cup of milk. Also, be aware that the only milks with any significant protein content are soy and hemp. In addition, make sure your milk is enriched with nutrients commonly found in dairy, like calcium and vitamin D.

Photo by: Nicole S. Young ©Nicole S. Young

Nicole S. Young, Nicole S. Young

Macaroni and “Cheese”

Pasta, like all starches, is vegan (assuming it is not made with eggs). So large amounts of vegan refined-starch products are no better than their non-vegan alternatives. And with vegan cheese, odds are you’re not getting the nutrients associated dairy cheese (protein and calcium); you may just be getting oil and thickeners.

Processed “Meats”

A number of minimally processed vegan protein options exist, such as tofu, seitan and tempeh. However, food manufacturers are quick to coat them (or textured vegetable protein) with breading, oil and/or stabilizers or additives to morph them into your favorite fake meat. Check the label of your preferred vegan protein sources, as some are better than others. Watch out for the usual offenders: very long ingredient lists, added sugars, added oils, etc.

Notice that the majority of these foods are processed, and contain the same junky ingredients that most people should avoid, vegan or otherwise: excess oil, sugar and refined starches. While certain specialty foods may help vegans achieve their daily needs for protein, vitamin B12, iron, calcium, etc., vegans (and everyone else, for that matter), should eat real food when possible.

Here are a few nutritious “real food” vegan meal options:

Vegan Lentil Burgers (pictured at top)

Related Links:

Through his book and blog, Death of the Diet, Jason Machowsky, MS, RD, CSCS, empowers people to live the life they want by integrating healthy eating and physical activity habits into their daily routines. You can follow him on Twitter @JMachowskyRDFit.

Next Up

The Veggie Table: Foods That Sound Vegan, But Really Aren't

Foods that sound like they be meat and dairy free, like vegetable soup or non-dairy creamer often contain ingredients you're not expecting. Be sure to check labels and ask your server at restaurants what foods contain, especially for the foods on this list.

10 Foods You Aren’t Storing Properly

Learn tips for properly storing healthy foods.

Food News: Chains Offering Vegan Fast-Food Options

Convenience store 7-Eleven is now offering vegan meals, and there are vegan options at Johnny Rockets, PF Changs Pizza Hut and Dairy Queen, too.

10 Healthy Foods You Aren’t Eating (But Should Be)

Eat these 10 nutrient powerhouse foods from Healthy Eats that most folks are missing out on.

9 Valentine’s Day Food Experiences That Aren’t Just a Candlelit Dinner

On the hunt for an out-of-the-box date idea? Look no further.