Homemade vs. Store-Bought: Eggnog

Are you planning to celebrate with this creamy classic this holiday season? Do you buy it in the carton or make your own? Which is the better way to go for this holiday treat?
Eggnog 1

Eggnog 1

Eggnog with Spices Sprinkled on Top in a White Mug

©Food Stylist: Jamie Kimm

Food Stylist: Jamie Kimm

Are you planning to celebrate with this creamy classic this holiday season? Do you buy it in the carton or make your own? Which is the better way to go for this holiday treat?
What is Eggnog?

A decadent concoction of cream and milk along with eggs, sugar and nutmeg -- it’s easy to see how the calories and fat in eggnog can soar. Commonly spiked with rum, brandy or whiskey, the “adult version” will pack in even more calories (about 100 for every shot of booze).

Store-bought

You’ll find festive cartons of chilled nog in the refrigerator section of the grocery store from Halloween through New Years. Made with the typical ingredients (minus the alcohol), you’ll also find thickeners and stabilizers, artificial colors and flavors; some are also sweetened with high fructose corn syrup. One-half cup typically has 170 calories and 8 grams of fat.

Homemade

Making your own eggnog will spare you the additives found in store-bought varieties but a traditional recipe will be similar in calories and fat. You can lighten things up using low fat dairy products and going light on the sugar. Low calorie flavorings like orange zest, vanilla and cinnamon can also give your homemade eggnog a boost.

Bottom Line: Make your own eggnog so you can control the quality and the amount of the ingredients – especially the high calorie ones.

Recipes to Try:
TELL US: Which do you prefer -- homemade or store-bought eggnog?
Keep Reading

Next Up

Food Fight: Eggnog vs. Hot Cocoa

'Tis the season for eggnog and hot chocolate. Find out which is the most sensible choice – it all comes down to how you make it.

Restaurant Dishes vs. Homemade Dishes

Ever wonder how many calories you'd save by making your favorite restaurant dishes at home? You'll be shocked when you see the numbers.

6 DIY Versions of Store-Bought Snacks

Try these can't-miss recipes for homemade versions of supermarket favorites like granola bars, graham crackers, cereal bars and cheddar cheese crackers.

How to Dress Up a Store-Bought Thanksgiving

Sometimes you need to serve a few store-bought items (with a little homemade touch) to save time at your turkey day feast.

Store-Bought Juice Blends: Are They Healthy?

Store shelves are lined with juice blends promising various health benefits. But are they really as healthy as they’re hyped up to be?

Store-Bought Snack Packs for Kids

Healthier snack packs your kids will love.

5 Chocolatey Treats Better Than a Box of Store-Bought Truffles — Comfort Food Feast

Give your valentine the gift of chocolate with homemade chocolate dessert recipes.

 7 Summer Slaws That Put the Store-Bought Stuff to Shame

Add crunch to tacos, pulled pork and more with these creative takes on classic coleslaw.

How to Upgrade Store-Bought Barbecue Sauce

Learn how to transform everyday barbecue sauce so that it has the flavors you're craving.