Make Your Own Tomato Sauce

We’ve taste tested the jarred stuff, but nothing beats a homemade batch of tomato sauce loaded with vitamins C and A, potassium and the antioxidant lycopene. With tomato season in full swing, don’t let extra tomatoes go to waste.
tomato sauce

Photo by: Brian Kennedy ©2013, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Brian Kennedy , 2013, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

We're celebrating tomatoes this week on Healthy Eats, so we're cooking up a classic.  We’ve taste tested the jarred stuff, but nothing beats a homemade batch of tomato sauce loaded with vitamins C and A, potassium and the antioxidant lycopene. With tomato season in full swing, don’t let extra tomatoes go to waste!

Why Make Your Own?

The canned and jarred stuff may be a good once-in-a-while substitute, but anything processed always has added preservatives, plus many jarred brands are heavy-handed with the olive oil. Salt and sugar are also added, so it's very important to check the labels before settling for your favorite brand. Check out the results from our jarred tomato sauce taste test.

The Tomatoes

Cook up a batch of homemade tomato sauce — actually, make that a double batch and freeze half for later.  Large and small tomatoes work equally well.  If using large tomatoes, like beefsteak and plum, the first step is removing the skin.  Using a paring knife, core the tomatoes and cut a shallow "X" on the bottom. Place tomatoes in a pot of boiling water for 30 to 60 seconds, or until skin begins to loosen. Remove tomatoes with a slotted spoon and transfer to a large bowl of ice water. Once cool, remove skin and seeds, then roughly chop.

If you’re pressed for time, freeze cored, peeled tomatoes and cook them up in the winter. You can also use canned tomatoes when tomato season ends.

The Seasonings

Onions, garlic, oregano, basil, and olive oil are tomato sauce basics. Other fave tomato sauce spices: parsley, bay leaf and thyme, and fennel seed. Use fresh or dried herbs, depending on what you’ve got around — remember, use less of the more potent dried herbs. Add a touch of red wine or red wine vinegar for a little extra zing. If you’re looking to spice it up, add red pepper flakes or a jalapeno or serrano pepper (or two).

To start, saute onions and garlic, then add prepared tomatoes. For a more concentrated sauce, cook longer or for a more “raw” sauce give the tomatoes a quick sauté. Dana likes to  roast, then puree, tomatoes when making sauce. For a smoother sauce, puree in a blender (or immersion blender) or leave it chunky.

Recipes to Try:
TELL US: What’s your favorite way to enjoy homemade tomato sauce?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

More Tomato Coverage:

Next Up

How to Make Your Own Spiced Nuts

Enjoy all the flavor of this satisfying snack, without all the sodium and extra oil packaged varieties tend to come with.

Yes, You Can Make Your Own Yule Log

Whether you’re a newb or a pro in the kitchen, you can wow friends and family with this classic Christmas dessert.

How to Make a Basic Tomato Sauce: A Step-by-Step Guide

Read these simple steps for making a delicious tomato sauce, then watch our how-to video.

5 Fun Things To Do With Tomato Sauce

When the season comes to a close, don’t let those fresh tomatoes go to waste! Make your own tomato sauce, then freeze and use it these 5 ways.

How to Make TikTok’s Famous Boat Dip and Customize It to Your Own Taste

A recipe developer shares simple ways to tweak the viral recipe.

This Is the Real Reason You Should Make Homemade Cranberry Sauce for Thanksgiving

Even if you’re having a small celebration, make a double batch!

Make Your Own Cranberry Sauce

I love cranberry sauce any time of year, but it's a must-have around Thanksgiving. As I gear up for the holiday, I’m all about finding creative new recipes. Forgo the canned stuff -- it's usually packed with HFCS -- and discover the taste of real, homemade cranberry sauce. Be sure to make lots so you’ll have leftovers for those post-Thanksgiving turkey sandwiches.

Make Your Own BBQ Sauce

Add extra sizzle to your cookouts. Whip up a batch of homemade barbecue sauce to slather on burgers, chops, chicken, seafood and veggies. The best part is, you control the ingredients.

Make Your Own Pudding

When I was a little girl, my dad’s specialty was chocolate pudding. Believe me, if my dad can do it so can you (burnt eggs were also on the menu).

Make Your Own Jam

Many store-bought jams, jellies and preserves contain more sugar than fruit. While you do need some sugar, it’s really the fruit you want to taste! Simple ingredients and a little bit of simmering and you’ll have the best tasting fruit spread imaginable.