Savor Fall Flavors with a Pepper and Pie Cocktail

If you’re searching for a craft cocktail to warm you up, look no further than an autumnal Pepper and Pie Cocktail from Watershed Distillery.

On a recent culinary tour of Columbus, Ohio, I had the chance to sample the local spirit-maker’s small-batch bourbon, gin and vodka, as well as cocktails from Alex Chien, bar manager of the soon-to-open Watershed Kitchen & Bar. Everyone raved about Alex’s refreshing cocktail made with tomato water, grapefruit, tarragon and Watershed’s Four Peel Gin (which, in addition to the usual juniper, is made with four citrus peels: orange, grapefruit, lemon and lime).

I’ve been craving Chien’s creative craft cocktails ever since, so I asked him to share a drink recipe with Healthy Eats for the season. His Pepper and Pie Cocktail harnesses fall’s best flavors — warming bourbon, apple cider, pumpkin puree, fresh apples and rosemary — in a single glass that drinks splendidly alongside holiday fare.

Pepper and Pie Cocktail

Recipe courtesy of Watershed Distillery

Yield: 1 serving


1 1/2 ounces Watershed Distillery Bourbon

1 ounce apple cider

3/4 ounce lemon juice

1/2 ounce honey simple syrup*

2 pinches rosemary, plus 1 sprig for garnish

1 barspoon pumpkin puree

Cracked black pepper, to taste

Soda water

1 apple, sliced, for garnish


Add bourbon, apple cider, lemon juice, honey simple syrup, rosemary, pumpkin puree and black pepper to a cocktail shaker and shake.

Fill a Collins glass with ice and strain cocktail into glass. Top with soda and stir.

Garnish with a rosemary sprig and an “apple fan” with cracked black pepper.

*Make honey simple syrup by combining two parts honey and one part water in a saucepan and heating until honey has dissolved.

Per serving: Calories 141; Fat 0 grams (Saturated 0 grams); Cholesterol 0 milligrams; Sodium 1 milligram; Carbohydrate 12 grams; Fiber 0 grams; Sugars 10 grams; Protein 0 grams

Related Links:

Spike It: Apple Cider-Bourbon Caramel Sauce

Spike It: Boozy Spiced Pumpkin Bread

7 Fall Cocktails to Cozy Up With

50 States of Cocktails

Photo courtesy of Watershed Distillery

Next Up

Flavor Bomb Cocktail Cubes

Bring your favorite classic cocktails to the next level with these fast and flavorful ice cubes.

Fall Cocktails You’ll Want to Sip Outside

These pair best with a fire pit and friends!

Move Over Pumpkin — Caramel Is the Real Hero of Fall Flavor

There's so much more to caramel than dipped apples.

Fall Fest: 5 Favorite Fall Salads

It's sad when fresh, juicy tomatoes disappear from farmers' markets, but there is an upside: it's time for fall salads, with earthy root veggies and hearty greens. Here are 5 of our favorite combinations.

Flavor Your Mayo

Add a twist to sandwiches or tacos with custom mayonnaise: Mix plain mayo with citrus zest or juice, fresh herbs, chopped olives or a condiment like pesto or Sriracha.

Related Pages